You are here:   Civilisation >  Books > A Personal Story of Memory and Survival
 

Schama's story, though, is not only about the divine Word; human words also play a large part, and this is another strength of this history, which is not only about power politics and religious struggles, but also about ordinary life. "Jewish life is Jewish words," from the everyday babble preserved in papyri and Genizah fragments, to the wide-ranging conversations of the Talmud, to the sublime and often erotic poetry of Samuel Ibn Nagrela and Judah Hallevi. And when the words run out there are also pictures, although, as Schama astutely remarks, the pictures are often adorned with words, and sometimes are even made from words. The space given to pictures — whether synagogue frescoes and mosaics, manuscript illustrations or micrography — is one of the admirable features of the book, but Schama is careful to stress that Judaism, "the religion of the word", never became a culture of icons: "picturing was the handmaid of words."

There is a third dimension, too, to the subtitle Finding the Words: Simon Schama's own quest to find the right words in which to couch the story of the Jews. Schama has a real gift for narrative, and at his best he has the direct simplicity that I admire in the poet Peter Levi. Schama can be poetic too, and has powers of vivid description.

The only stylistic feature that mars the prose for me is his occasional descent into an exaggeratedly jokey New York Yiddish vernacular, which seems quite inappropriate both to Schama himself and to the story he is telling. It is vain, I suppose, to speculate about what this quirk is meant to achieve.

The Story of the Jews is told as a personal story, and it often has the exalted, lyrical quality of a declaration of love. This is the impression above all that stayed with me as I came to the end of my reading. I do not know any other Jewish history that has this haunting quality. There are others that rehearse the story more reliably but more prosaically; Simon Schama enchants and captivates. 

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
Juggling For A Cure
November 10th, 2013
11:11 PM
Reading about Schama's work brings me back to my reading the Newbery Medal winner, Number the Stars, by Lois Lowry. About succeeding against the odds, it is a classic children’s book about a Danish Jewish family escaping by boat at night to Sweden.

elixelx
November 9th, 2013
6:11 AM
There is a lot, A LOT, more here than meets the eye. Twin hemispheres, one with a priori ramblings, one with a posteriori suggestions, with letters of an ALPHABET (something no other culture had ever developed) came down with Moses from the mountain. The Rabbis said ¨"Horeed b'Yado" (held in his hands" should be read as "Herut b'Yado" (Freedom in his hands) The tablets of stone were a model of the human brain. Learn to manipulate the letters and all things become possible; don't learn the letters and you remain a slave forever... Chomski said (half correct as usual) "The Brain is a black box with a language-acquisition device within" It was NOT a black box, but a gold box that was capable of killing and curing...just like the human brain... There is more, A LOT MORE, to the Matan Torah, that our bulbous brains have not yet illuminated..but it's coming...

david levavi
October 31st, 2013
1:10 PM
Hopefully Schama makes mention of the superior efficiency of written Hebrew. A consonantal language absent vowels, Hebrew requires significantly less substrate and ink to transcribe than languages with vowels. When the substrate is parchment and the ink is laboriously homemade, this is an important advantage.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.