You are here:   Academia > ONLINE ONLY: Education It's Not
 

Perhaps fiction is the best way to challenge the hypocrisies and philistinism of our times. After all, the dehumanising effects of modernity has been a central preoccupation of literature since the Romantic period. Whether immiserated by urbanisation and the factory system in Dickens and Victor Hugo, or crushed by the state bureaucracy in the works of Gogol and Kafka, the modern hero struggles to break free from everything that is inhuman and reductive.

The hero of my novel is engaged in the same struggle as Frankie is in real life: he has to make sense of the world despite the best efforts of the authorities to belittle, confuse and isolate his experiences. And if he is going to search for meaning and true education, he knows he will have to do so outside the system, for the system is interested only in measurable results. Gradually he comes to realise that, in treating the young like this, our society is committing an injustice against the human spirit which is indefensible on anyone's terms. ‘To speak a language,' Franz Fanon wrote, ‘is to take on a world, a culture.' And to be deprived of language - the language of the wider world, and of the past with all its tragedies, sufferings and achievements - is to be cut off from the means of entering that world, or even discovering that it exists.

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
Michael Sweeney
September 30th, 2008
11:09 PM
I am very sympathetic to the writer's message. However, I obtained an 'A' grade for history at A level in 1984 but understood the dissolution of the monasteries far more from CJ Sansom's novels than Geoffrey Elton. I recall we learned much about Fascism and nothing about the British Empire (which I believe had an immense influence on the world as it is today - I am regularly asked why does everybody speak English from children and foreigners alike) as well as nothing about Wellington or Nelson. I studied English at University, but Milton was never introduced to us on any curriculum. There is a real problem that there is so much more history and literature than there was 50 years ago - more published works, different approaches to subject matter (Stalingrad and Kursk are now regarded as more pivotal than D-Day for example). But the broad sweep of a subject can be taught - it isn't, and compounds our ignorance. Everybody should be compelled to read the Tempest though.

William Jolliffe
August 25th, 2008
1:08 PM
This article is excellent in substance and presentation. It informs about failing education today, in a concise style which should shame many teachers & journalists today. Mr Shaw has struck a blow for excellence by what he states and how he writes. PS it is hard to read the word 'TYPE' in the captcha below.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.