You are here:   Bonnie Greer > Census That Revealed a Troubling Future
 

Such statements are so selective as to be wholly disingenuous. Until the latter half of the last century, Britain had almost negligible levels of immigration. Unlike America, we were never in fact "a nation of immigrants". And although there was often a trickle of people moving here, including Jews and Huguenots who overwhelmingly integrated into the culture, the simple scale was in a wholly separate league to the mass immigration we have seen in recent years. Roughly 50,000 Huguenots came to Britain after 1681. This was equal to a couple of months of immigration by the turn of the 21st century. The entire Ugandan Asian immigration into Britain in the early 1970s (caused by Idi Amin's expulsion of Asians from Uganda) numbered around 30,000. This constituted six weeks' worth of immigration by the late 1990s.

Yet despite these facts, one popular way to ignore the change in recent years has been to pretend that the history is different. Taxpayer-funded institutions, including schools, excel at this argument. It is a way to diminish the problem — most noticeably the problem of integration — by claiming that there is no problem, or at least no unique problem. It pretends that whatever our challenges, and whatever we are experiencing, it is just normal.

Other attempts to dissemble around the facts have been even more outrageous. Most disturbing are those implicit and explicit claims which respond to mass immigration by pretending either that the British do not have a culture, or that what culture and identity we have is so uniquely bad that it should not be mourned when it is destroyed.

Here is Bonnie Greer again on Newsnight: "There's always this failsafe, spoken or unspoken, that there is a British identity. That's always interesting to me. I think one of the geniuses of the British — of being British — is that there isn't this sort of rock-solid definition of identity that an American has."

It is hard to think of another country where this would be acceptable: your culture has always been like this — it never really existed.

In 2006 Channel 4 took enormous delight in taking a group of white British people whom it clearly believed were racists — including Norman Tebbit — and doing DNA tests on them for a documentary, 100% English?  These were used to prove that all were in fact "foreigners". Nobody would be so rude as to do this to any other group of people. But with British people, different rules of engagement were deemed to apply. There existed an apparent desire to deny the British — alone of all people — an identity. In the absence of any ability to manage immigration, this is how our public figures have dealt with the issue.

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
Irish
March 3rd, 2013
3:03 AM
Thumbs up to john s. The three you mention were so spot on they made me laugh, and they can't even see it!

Anonymous
March 3rd, 2013
2:03 AM
It was our British Govts that did it ,it wasnt the people You say tough that its happening in Britain ,we the people are not to blame ,,so stop talking outa your backside Ram.

Miguel
March 1st, 2013
8:03 PM
Beijing will never be majority non-Chinese, Lagos will never be majority non-African... Shall I go on? So then why is it okay that EVERY country founded by Europeans has to be over-run by the Third World?

George
March 1st, 2013
3:03 PM
Ram & Glen - are you cerebrally challenged? Murray addresses those points in the article.

Gerónimo Anónimo
March 1st, 2013
3:03 AM
Buy and read Into the Cannibal's Pot by Ilana Mercer. It's frightening but must be read.

john s
March 1st, 2013
2:03 AM
So Glen, Sam and Ram, did Mr Murray pay you to illustrate the very arguments he so totally destroys in the article? You could not have done a better job.

Ram
February 28th, 2013
5:02 PM
The author says: "Until the latter half of the last century, Britain had almost negligible levels of immigration. Unlike America, we were never in fact "a nation of immigrants". Query out of sheer curiousity.....er, were you either then or before a nation of EMIGRANTS on any scale? Or are you saying its fine and dandy for Britons to arbirarily take over North America, Australia, New Zealand and dominate and make use of countless other lands...but NOT OK for coloured folks to come the other way as migrants? The author says: We long ago reached the point where the only thing white Britons can do is to remain silent about the change in their country. Ignored for a generation, they are expected to get on, silently but happily, with abolishing themselves, accepting the knocks and respecting the loss of their country. "Get over it. It's nothing new. You're terrible. You're nothing." Who has said this? Is sharing British identity with some coloured folks the end of the world? Don't THEY read Shakespeare?

Delmar Jackson
February 28th, 2013
2:02 AM
I wish I could express myself as well as this author can on so imortant an issue as immigration. I can't agree with Mr Murray more. I feel that immigration is being used for power,profit and punishment. Those that profit from immigrants are those that hire immigrants and the immigrants themselves, leaving the rest of us to pay for our own dispossession. All of the profits go to those at the top and the communiteis are burdened with all the social,economic and environmental costs. Politicians and ethnic advocates also profit from the power of immigrant votes and use immigration to punish those that want less immigration. I would quibble with one statement, we here in america, are not a nation of immigrants, not yet anyway, we are a nation of citizens that have been betrayed by both parties and the media on immigration for decades. It is hard to express how much anger I feel for those who have enabled this situation. Those in the media like to smear those like me that want less immigration with vile damaging names like xenophobe ,nativist,anti immigrant,racist and bigot , I am supposed to hate all immigrants. What they do not realize is I don't hate immigrants, immigrants are a symptom, not the problem, if I hate anyone it is my fellow citizen that believes diversity and the destruction of my country is more important than Unity, and that my culture,history,language and morals and values should be thrown into a trash heap or shallow grave. multiculturalism is a 7 syllable word with a 7 syllable defintition. Mul ti cul tur al is m Ge ting rid of white peo ple. This will not end well.

Glen
February 28th, 2013
12:02 AM
Douglas, every country is getting more diverse not just Britain. And Britain has previously been a nation of emigrants to USA, Australia, Canada. By the way the same DNA testing was carried out on Black Brazilians as 100% English with similar results. I am sorry you are uncomfortable with our changing demographics. Perhaps you could emigrate to North Pole? It's all white!

Sam
February 28th, 2013
12:02 AM
I wonder what Jean Raspail (The Camp of the Saints) might make of this?

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.