You are here:   Blogs >Peter Whittle > Have a Rotten Day
Standpoint Blogs
 
 
Peter Whittle
Wednesday 8th September 2010
Have a Rotten Day

Back from my vacation in California. I've traveled numerous times to the US over the past twenty years and yet, even though I should expect it, I am still struck on my return each time by the spikey, increasingly bloody-mindedness which courses through everyday life in Britain. The transactions in shops done in complete, surly silence. The suppressed aggression between total strangers. The lack of even the most basic of civic acknowledgements. For a long time, Americans held to a view of the British as maybe stuffy but always courteous. That has, I think, finally gone. They still admire our older thespians (or Sir Hopkins and Dame Dench as they endearingly refer to them), but something tells them that it is Ricky Gervais who now represents true British culture.

So many qualities which once defined us are now to be found in the US. We have, if you like, switched. Wanton rudeness, hostility and loudness are now the currency of London, not New York, whose inhabitants strike you as positively benign, modest and helpful by comparison. Our new behaviour is not, however borne of a sense of brash competitiveness, but from anger and resentment.

My experience of America has I think been wide enough not to be rose-tinted. During my time spent there (which included a five year stint in LA) I think I never witnessed the kind of everyday anti-social behaviour which we have become used to here - the kind of actions which fall well under the radar of criminality but which manage to utterly alienate and disturb. LA for example might well be one of America's most murderous cities; but ordinary everday civil life is infinitely safer, less stuffed with the kind of incidents which we have become used to and tolerate.

I'd say this is because they still know who they are. And, despite being the land of supposedly rampant, capitalist individualism, there is a far greater sense of civic spirit, of voluntary collectivsim. As that archetypal English eccentric and ex-pat Quentin Crisp once said: in America, the system is cruel but the people are benign, in Britain the system is benign, but the people...    

 

Tags:
 
Like this article? Share, save or print using the icons below
Delicious   Digg   StumbleUpon   Propeller   Reddit   Magnoliacom   Newsvine   Furl   Facebook   Google   Yahoo   Technorati   Icerocket   Print   Mail   Twitter   
Share/Save
 
 
 
Masha
September 8th, 2010
8:09 PM
Ah, but you should move to the north of England! I moved here after many decades in London. Where I am (Sheffield) every person is treated as a person. There is not the aggression, naked or otherwise.People say they are happy. I'd forgotten what it was like not to have nagging fear and suspicion when on public transport. Everybody speaks!

Charlie Griffith
September 8th, 2010
8:09 PM
This 79 year old American was an expat in Hong Kong for the six years I worked at KaiTak. I lived in nearby Kowloon Tong....and experienced then a kindly but distant disdain which ceased when the local Brits in controlling jobs there understood that I was not to be patronized. I was a Manager in my own right. We got along fine afterwards, but my later apparent "acceptance" was always tinged by my being American....or so I thought. There remained always a slight air towards anyone not properly British. So, permit, if you will, an American-sourced observation after all of these years and the loss of your empire.....I think this newly apparent rudeness in London my be due to some sort of unconscious reflex towards the huge influx of alien former colonial subjects....a latent resentment to the reversal of fortunes since even as late as the 1960's...not to mention the inter-war years. Just a thought....

Patrick Corden
September 8th, 2010
5:09 PM
As British expats living in LA after a trial retirement in the UK last year my wife and I can only endorse what Peter says. We spent a couple of years in Dorset and London trying to find that oh so elusive past that has so sadly finally perished under the past decade of social erosion. The landscape and architecture is still mostly there, certainly an improvement on the terrible 60's phase but the people have drastically changed. Just try saying a simple "good morning" to a stranger during your morning walk in Dorset or London and one will experience the huge difference to there and here. As for the "suppressed aggression" mentioned by Peter, we used to 'shiver' sometimes just walking through Dorchester's High Street and it wasn't because we were cold.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
 
About Peter Whittle

Peter Whittle is director of the New Culture Forum and author of Look at Me: Celebrating the Self in Modern Britain and Private Views: Voices from the Front Line of British Culture.

Recent Blog Posts
Blog List
More Posts
Popular Standpoint topics