You are here:   Dispatches > ONLINE ONLY: Beirut: Blood Holiday
 
The Lebanese are fully aware of the nature of Kuntar's crimes. While some are truly appalled, the fact is that bludgeoning the head of a four-year-old child is hardly anomalous in the context of a military strategy that for over half a century has intentionally targeted civilians. After all, it is not as though Kuntar crossed the boundaries of decency so carefully articulated by Yasser Arafat, Ayman Al-Zawahiri and Osama Bin Ladin. So, if the leaders of Lebanon's pro-democracy gathering will not denounce Kuntar's crimes or Hezbollah's celebration it is not merely because they lack courage. Rather, it is because even the Sunnis, as much as they despise the "Party of God", are so steeped in the same bloody history that they cannot imagine another course. What is unique about Hezbollah's coming out party for Kuntar is that it illustrates how the culture of death ("Death to Israel, Death to America.") may end by consuming itself. As Hezbollah proved in its blitzkrieg of Beirut in May, Lebanese lives, Arab lives, Muslim lives are also of little account if they stand against the "Islamic resistance". Moreover, the Kuntar episode shows that the Shiite militia has little regard for even Shiites. After all, insofar as freeing Kuntar was Nasrallah's casus belli for the July 2006 war [it was to force Kuntar's release that Hezbollah raided Israel and kidnapped two soldiers] the Lebanese Shiite community "martyred" 1200 of its own in order to vouchsafe Nasrallah's "faithful promise". Twelve hundred for one is a bargain suicidal in both its math and its ethics.

Self destruction is arguably the inevitable destination for a group that, as Martin Kramer details here, made its world debut with suicide operations during the Lebanese civil wars.

The first car-bomb "martyrdom operation" was November 11, 1982 when a Hezbollah fighter killed seventy-four Israeli soldiers and fourteen others. Then came a series of spectacular attacks, culminating in the1983 US Marine Barracks bombing at the Beirut airport. Amal, another Shiite organization, understood that Hezbollah's martyrdom operations were winning them prestige and power in the Shiite community, and tried to match is rival.

As the two Shiite organizations competed for martyrs, they started sending out their young men on ill-conceived operations that failed to kill any of the enemy and achieved only the deaths of the martyrs themselves. That is, they were suicides.

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
alzaebo
July 30th, 2008
9:07 PM
Get your enemies to kill your other enemies. This is a consequence of first cousin marraige: expendable herd members. It's all about the ethnic populations, and the inability to grow, rather than take, resources.

Anonymous
July 29th, 2008
8:07 AM
i agree that many lebanese were not happy with the celebrations that took place, however the article in my opinion is very much one-sided. you can not equate Hezbollah with osama and his gang. the complexities of lebanese politics and history is hardly mentioned here or brought to light. i am in lebanon and this article bring no justice to the overwelming feelings felt in this country. the legitamacy of the 'western back' government is a joke. how could you miss that. they have no legitamacy.

Noga
July 26th, 2008
2:07 AM
Boogie said: "Arabs killed by other Arabs are apparently not as dead as those killed by Israelis." _______________________________ Andre Gluckmann called it "The Jerusalem Syndrome" "...On the scales of world opinion, some Muslim corpses are light as a feather, and others weigh tonnes. Two measures, two weights. The daily terrorist attacks on civilians in Baghdad, killing 50 people or more, are checked off in reports under the heading of miscellaneous, while the bomb that took 28 lives in Qana is denounced as a crime against humanity. Only a few intellectuals like Bernard-Henri Lévy or Magdi Allam, chief editor of the Corriere della Sera, find this surprising. Why do the 200,000 slaughtered Muslims of Darfur not arouse even half a quarter of the fury caused by 200-times fewer dead in Lebanon? Must we deduce that Muslims killed by other Muslims don't count - whether in the eyes of Muslim authorities or viewed through the bad conscience of the west? This conclusion has its weak spots, because if the Russian Army - Christian, and blessed by their popes - razes the capital of Chechnian Muslims (Grosny, with 400,000 residents) killing tens of thousands of children in the process, this doesn't count either. The Security Council does not hold meeting after meeting, and the Organization of Islamic States piously averts its eyes. From that we may conclude that the world is appalled only when a Muslim is killed by Israelis." http://www.signandsight.com/features/894.html

Khaled
July 26th, 2008
1:07 AM
Interesting article from both an on the ground perspective and from a Hezbollah tactical perspective. There was another really good one in the Jerusalem Post recently.

Anonymous
July 25th, 2008
9:07 PM
Austin, I do not believe everything I read; and, in particular, I do not believe you. As far as I'm concerned, the Lebanon 'celebrations' are on a par with Nuremberg ralies in the 1930's Germany. Need I say more?

Anonymous
July 25th, 2008
5:07 PM
Austin; Were all those phantom children Hezbollah fighters? The majority of killed Iraqis were killed by other Iraqis. The biggest killers of Arabs are other Arabs, not Israelis.

Peter Saffian
July 25th, 2008
11:07 AM
Austin, you are the one who should open his eyes. The 1200 Lebanese who died in the July war were mostly Hizbullah fighters not children. As for the 'million Iraqis' allegedly killed since the Coalition invaded - that is pure fantasy - a propaganda number without factual basis.

Austin
July 25th, 2008
1:07 AM
What was that Boogie? What about the 1200 Lebanese killed by Israel in the July war of 2006? Mostly children! Or more than one million Iraqis killed since the U.S. invaded? Do you believe everything you read? Fanaticism is a disease. Open your eyes.

BOOGIE
July 24th, 2008
2:07 PM
“Despite all the conflicts among the Arabs themselves, this still comes first” Mindboggling. Saddam kills some 800,000 people and that barely registers, but IDF rockets kills a dozen Palestinian civilians and it’s a collective outrage. Arabs killed by other Arabs are apparently not as dead as those killed by Israelis.

Nate
July 24th, 2008
12:07 PM
It's a shame some people must create societal divisions in order to validate their own existence and actions.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
More Dispatches
Popular Standpoint topics