You are here:   Features > Muslim Women Deserve Better than Sharia Law
 
"This is not an Islamic country, which is why so many of us came to live here. If sharia were to become part of the legal system it would be a disaster for women," says Jaan. "Many are not even aware of their rights so they think sharia is the proper law."

I spoke to Aatifa, a religious Muslim woman living in Leicester who has been living in temporary accommodation since her husband threw her out. "He wanted to bring home a new wife," says Aatifa, "but I cannot cope with that." Aatifa complained and her husband took her to the sharia court in their mosque. "He was told it was fine to bring back another wife, even up to three more. I pleaded with the imam to listen to my concerns, but because we have not had children yet, it was ruled that I had not fulfilled my duties as a wife and had no rights." Polygamy is of course illegal under UK law, but not under sharia.

John Bowen, author of Blaming Islam, is an anthropologist based at Washington University in St Louis. He specialises in comparative social studies of Islam across the world. Bowen has found that Britain is unique in having a well-developed network of sharia courts, and has interviewed imams, scholars and members of the public who access them. He argues that sharia councils do not have any legal power, and are therefore harmless bodies that simply allow people to settle disputes without accessing mainstream courts. I asked Bowen what he thought about such bodies making decisions on divorce when women cite domestic violence. "The accusation is that sharia councils try to bring couples back together, but this is the case with mainstream law, which is why there is waiting time before a divorce, mediation and couples counselling. A reconciliation and a joint meeting of the husband and wife is always urged."

But under UK law, women do not have to ask for permission from their violent husband, self-appointed community leader or religious representative in order to be granted a divorce. I asked Bowen if he was concerned about women who are frightened of their imam and are told by a sharia court that they must return to a violent husband. "If somebody is given a sharia ruling they don't like they can just go to the [secular] court and get another," he replied. But what about those women who are married in Islamic ceremonies, speak little English, and believe that the word of the imam is law?

Sharia is an important tool with which the Islamist movement restricts women's freedom. There is a link between sharia and the rise of Islamism, including groups like Islamic State or the Muslim Brotherhood. Many, however, whether naively or deliberately, fail to see it. The legitimisation of sharia has a negative effect on women, children and society as a whole. These effects are noticeable from Iraq to Iran and Saudi Arabia as well as in Britain.

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
Dana
January 13th, 2015
1:01 AM
Not true that adoptees do not inherit under sharia law. But they inherit from their biological parents, not their adoptive parents. I would actually prefer that over the way Westerners do adoption because they're rather like transsexuals in that way--reality is reality because I say it is reality, never mind what the actual facts are. Western adoption involves falsifying a legal document and forcing a mother to pretend she never birthed her child and the child to pretend genetic strangers are his or her parents. Islam doesn't allow that--and in the process also accidentally protects against incest and the disinheritance of children and the cutting off of adults from their genetic and medical history. Don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. There are undoubtedly Muslim tenets you would agree with, even as there are many you wouldn't.

Anonymous
December 20th, 2014
7:12 AM
And she is an anti Israeli, pro Palestinian communist.

amcdonald
October 15th, 2014
10:10 PM
Our politicians seem content to let the islamified Birmingham schools revert to type. The main parties want the muslim votes. They`ll betray Israel for muslim votes. They`ll betray civilisation for muslim votes. Are the party leaders happy to be used as useful idiots by uber rich Islam ? There`s no Kaffir- Infidels Party to vote for. The closest to this is unPC `shambolically british` UKIP. They weren`t expensively uneducated at Eton and Cambridge and don`t have dodgy Politics,Philosophy and Economics degrees either.

Anonymous
October 14th, 2014
12:10 PM
It's about time we said no to all so called religious based groups trying to get their interpretation on how to live your life spread over the wider populace. No one should be held at law to the whims of an imam deciding what Mohammed would have thought on a particular topic. The Koran (and the rest of the religious texts were all written many many centuries ago and other than tenents like don't kill people (of whatever religion) not just fakirs, have no relevance today. It's about time we just said no to all religion and its insidious ways.

Janleenewell
October 10th, 2014
11:10 PM
What has been said is that this is the way that Islams want to Islamisise Europe and also America. Because with our laws we will let it happen.

amcdonald
October 9th, 2014
11:10 PM
The recent Sun front page muslim woman wearing a union jack flag will be duplicated by muslim women in Israel draping themselves in the Israeli flag? Inna from Femen is more precise in the Huffington Post (7/10/14)`Islam Is Peace`- But Islam is Also Isis. It looks like Polyglot5 is right too.

Polyglot5
October 8th, 2014
9:10 AM
Siddiqi is quick to resort to taqqya - strategy of lying to westerners in order to project a heavily sugar-coated image of Islam and shari'a. Don't believe a word of his mansplaining.

amcdonald
September 29th, 2014
1:09 PM
Presumably MAT has a list of women it has successfully helped in the past 35 years and they can be contacted to verify Shaykh Siddiqi`s claims ? And Shaykh Siddiqi is happy with the sharia divorce fee of £200 for men and £400 for women ? Does Shaykh S think muslim women deserve better than sharia law ? Or is he actually advocating it ? It`s handy for our intelligence services to know for sure who`s advocating sharia in this country.

Shaykh Siddiqi
September 26th, 2014
7:09 PM
You have reported inaccurately the fact that the 6 women withdrew their complaint to the police. In fact they had not reported the matter to the police and were encouraged by MAT in the first instance to report the matter to the domestic violence officer at the local police station. The women showed clear reluctance to do so as they clearly stated that this would not resolve their problem but create a whole myriad of problems and ultimately end the marriage. They stated that the police and the Social Services and/or most DV charities were inept and incapable of resolving their problems but contacting them would only cause the demise of their marriage. They approached MAT as it is the only organisation in the country that is capable of and has for the last 35 years helped women especially and sometimes men to eliminate any form of violence within the relationship and to maintain a healthy future with their spouses. Thus Julie Bindel is invited to first properly investigate the facts rather than misstate the truth. Please amend your article accordingly.

amcdonald
September 25th, 2014
11:09 PM
£200 for a man to divorce and £400 for a woman. And available on every muslim doorstep. Cheap cowboy-Islamic capitalism. And Michael Gove and David Cameron are saying/doing nothing ? Sending jets to bomb scumbag Islamic State abroad but actually ignoring the women victims here/home front and cutting funding to womens refuges ? !

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.