You are here:   Features > Migrant Crisis? Europe Hasn't Seen Anything Yet
 
Even here we are far beyond the current acceptable political discussion, yet barely scratching the surface of the problem. But the questions have to be asked. What system does Europe have in place to discern who is a legitimate refugee and who is an economic migrant? Is it fit for purpose? In Italy I asked every aid worker I could find if they knew of anybody being sent back home after arriving in European waters. Nobody could think of such a case. The truth is that once someone is here they stay because Europe cannot work out who is who (most people having deliberately come without papers) and even if they are clearly economic migrants they are never sent home. Europe had no workable system to do this when the movement was at a low-point. Now that it is at a historic high Europe has less than no system.

And then there is the question of the composition of the migrants. If this movement is indeed a movement of the genuinely dispossessed then why are almost all of them young men? In recent weeks the media has zoomed its cameras in on the occasional woman or child. But they are the rarities. On Lampedusa I saw only young men from sub-Saharan Africa. I saw no women. One of the first things that many of the arrivals did on getting to the island was to buy a SIM card and call home to tell their families that they had made it: families they will end up sending money to if they make any (largely in the underground economy) and whom they will often aim to bring over to join them.

And of course there is the question of integration. Does anybody, anywhere in Europe still think integration has happened to date? Almost every government, currently opening its borders to further migrants, has in fact accepted that it has not. Chancellor Merkel said as much in a speech five years ago, as David Cameron did four years ago. So why would integration happen when immigration is at the current historic highs, if it didn’t happen when immigration was at — remarkably — a comparative low? Some politicians want to blame the public for a lack of enthusiasm about importing millions more people into Europe. If they are looking for someone to blame for that attitude they could do worse than looking to the citizens of Dewsbury, Gennevilliers, Malmö and many other places in Europe anyone can name.

All of this, again, barely touches the beginning of the debate which our continent is so far away from having. But perhaps it brings me to the most crucial question of all. Assuming that the majority of the arrivals are economic migrants and that we are going to do little or nothing to prevent them coming, ought not Europeans to try to start thinking their way through the first-principles questions? Such as: “Is it the job of Europeans to give a better standard of living in our continent to anybody in the world who wants it?’

If public opinion polls are anything to go by it would seem that the publics of Europe already have an answer to a question their political representatives still dare not ask. In Hungary, Poland, Slovakia and other countries, politicians are trying to respond to public sentiment. But everywhere else the strain of sustaining the current disconnect is beginning to show. The Swedish government recently announced that it is going to take a further 80,000 refugees this year (around 1 per cent of its current population). It is a continuation of a more-than generous asylum policy which has seen Sweden boast of becoming a “humanitarian superpower”. But these things have consequences. One recent poll showed the only anti-immigration party in the country — the Sweden Democrats — for the first time leading the opinion polls. This party, often described as far-right, was until recently never polling above low single digits.

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
thejustcity
September 24th, 2015
6:09 PM
The other hypothetical question that needs to be posed, one which might be invaluable and instructive, is that in a war in a region between two opposing powers who share the same ideology and beliefs, for what reason should it be incumbent upon external and distant regions to take into their hearth every individual from the losing side in that conflict, when the ideology and beliefs of either are both incompatible with and deleterious to those regions?

amcdonald
September 24th, 2015
2:09 PM
All these pictures of refugees show the now TOTAL FAILURE OF ISLAM and it`s fictional Ummah. A prominent arab journalist (BBC...)thinks a russian and american led troops on the ground alliance is being organised to totally destroy Islamic State. That would make sense (like the alliance that destroyed the nazis in WW2). The heroic Kurdish Army deserves solidarity. Today we read of nearly 500 muslims crushed to death at Mecca. The only good news about Islam is its total historical collapse. Western civilisation and Enlightenment values are winning. It`s the triumph of pagan modernism and it`s science and culture.

Dougie
September 24th, 2015
1:09 PM
This is exactly the type of crisis that the EU was (or ought to have been) designed for. Now we can see the EU, from the Commission downwards, is totally useless there remains no possible reason for remaining a member.

Anonymous
September 24th, 2015
1:09 PM
happy are you douglas with the racist ignorant comments which always follow your articles.

Anon
September 24th, 2015
10:09 AM
What the hell is the Coudenhove-Kalergi plan? Sounds like some conspiracist crap to me.

Albert Zbingswiki
September 24th, 2015
10:09 AM
And still the elephant in the room remains the poisonous cancer of a religion which these people bring with them, which spreads death wherever it settles, and which dooms Europe to an oppressive future, as precious few have the nerve to stand up to it. Because, obviously, that would make them a 'phobe, which is the very, very worst thing one can be.

Peter Lee Goodchildmous
September 24th, 2015
9:09 AM
Visions of the Coudenhove-Kalergi plan coming to life. The elite, anonymous puppet masters are at work who control all our destinies......accidents don't just happen like wars, immigration - they are all caused by sometimes forces we are unaware of. The futility of individual thought and logic is nothing compared to the dark and powerful who pull our strings.

Alexander Tomsky
September 24th, 2015
7:09 AM
Spot on! Immigration in the US is not analogous. Americans are a political nation made up of former immigrants, the europeans are made of old small nations and absorbing newcomers is very difficult. But the real problem are the muslims; americans are lucky to have relatively few and given their political religion are able to absorb peacefully most of them

Mitchell Puttick
September 24th, 2015
6:09 AM
Douglas, Please come to Australia and speak on Q&A (Australia's version of Question time). We need a neo- conservative voice to speak some sense into the left (or at least attempt to).

Brian McInnis
September 24th, 2015
5:09 AM
'Many of us who live in Europe, love Europe as it is.' Nothing ever stays as it is for long, Douglas. You really should know that by now.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.