You are here:   Ed Hirsch > More Than ABCs in NYC
 

This is a far cry from what some in Britain are campaigning for. Shakespeare, they say, is irrelevant in the 21st century where technology rules. So what if our 16-year-olds write GCSE English essays (that pass) explaining how Romeo and Juliet met across a fish tank, and that Tybalt and Mercutio carry guns? Once, when trying to explain to an old family friend just how bad the situation in our schools is, I pointed out how so much history and literature simply isn't taught at all. His response? "When I send my children to school, I simply don't expect them to learn about 1066 and all that." I was stunned.

That is a fundamental difference between attitudes in Britain and America. Whatever the school, whatever its intake, few Americans would ever question teaching children about Abraham Lincoln or Thomas Jefferson. But here, somehow, teaching British history or great British writers is almost seen as morally wrong. The principal says goodbye: "I look forward to visiting your school next year and seeing similar things." I nod. "Yes," I say, "we'll open. We just have to."

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
Alex Bensky
April 10th, 2012
2:04 AM
I regret to say that in many American schools if they teach about George Washington it's mostly to talk about the fact that he was a slaveowner, or to highlight Lincoln's views on race which were not in accord with contemporary liberalism. Nor would many schools--both public (in our sense, government-supported) and private--see much use in teaching Shakespeare when there are black and Latino writers who are much more relevant, or so they claim. It's the students who are being robbed. My mother once told me that when she was about twelve, which means she and her mother would have been in the US about five years, her father somewhat longer (and none of them had come here speaking a word of English), she was trotted out proudly for the neighbors. "Judith is studying Shakespeare in school," my grandmother bragged. Further, if either set of grandparents had been told that their children should not learn about and admire Edison, or Washington, or Whitman, they would have screamed high and low. My grandparents' grandchildren have become doctors, university teachers, foreign service officers--I turned to the dark side and became a lawyer--businessmen, teachers, and so forth. There is a connection. Students are being robbed of opportunities to grow both as part of the work force and as citizens.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.