You are here:   Columns >  On the Contrary > The Beige of Beijing
 

I did myself no favours at China's Bookworm Literary Festival in March when I announced on stage that Beijing was "the ugliest city I'd ever seen". Even the expats were offended. Yet the problem wasn't simply my typical tactlessness. After a few days of trudging through that dingy fug, as ranks of monotonous, cheaply constructed tower blocks foreshortened into the gloom, I didn't think I was venturing an opinion, but stating a self-evident fact.

Though I'm no China expert, there may be some modest value to the fresh eye. The native Chinese and expats alike had over-adapted to their dystopic town and could no longer see it.

The air? I'd read the news reports, and fancied I was prepared. I wasn't. The atmosphere was so thick and brown that I could taste it. This hard-to-pin-down flavour (imagine sucking on a nickel in one cheek and on a multivitamin in the other — mmm) coated the entire inside of my mouth with a greasy, toxic film, inducing a mild but persistent nausea. Unless you're treated to the rare, much celebrated "blue-sky day" — when the wind disperses the auto and factory emissions, coal smoke and the singe from rice paddies being burnt off for spring planting — the coffee-stain air leeches the vibrancy from colours, all of which become variations on beige. Walking around Beijing is like watching the world on 1970s TV.

Thus despite an impressive absence of litter, everything is filthy-covered in the same dingy film that coated my mouth. The facades of buildings are paled over with particulates, the creases of dilapidated window frames emphasised by grime. Dull and lifeless, public shrubbery looks plastic. The very trees are dirty.

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
Chen Li
May 9th, 2013
11:05 AM
yes, the pollution is bad. yes, the buildings are ugly. but really, who cares? stop being so precious. I lived in London for 5-years, New York for 10, and numerous other cities in between, and nowhere, not a single grouping of people on earth measures up to Beijing at this exact moment in time. It's that simple, it's exciting. it's unregulated. it's moving fast, and anything, literally anything might happen. Watch now, as the usual bunch of 'poor-me' expats, bores and lost boys line-up to argue otherwise; give it up and move on. no one cares what you think.

vmomo
May 9th, 2013
9:05 AM
Uh, she's hit the nail on the head - we adapt way too easily to the air in BJ. Come on people - my apartment was built 30 years ago and looks like it's been there since the turn of the 20th century, there's a reason the buildings in Sichuan crumble when there's an earthquake.

The Krow
May 9th, 2013
7:05 AM
I think Shriver's "Even the expats were offended" reveals quite an interesting blind-spot. If she can describe herself as "a Londoner", why wouldn't the expats of Beijing feel a little offended about her knocking their hometown? To be fair, the air was quite bad when she came to visit - it's all looking a bit greener and cleaner this month.

Tom Miller
May 9th, 2013
7:05 AM
Actually, she's spot on. And say that as someone who's lived in Beijing for 11 years and written a book about China's cities.

William Poy Lee
May 9th, 2013
7:05 AM
I'm an American whose lived in Beijing for 4 years and yes, there oh so many small gems of neighborhoods, medium gems of cultural heritage, and bigger gems of stunning, modern, original architecture. I've enjoyed them all plus the great nightlife of bars, live music, and all-night discos. Yet, when Ms. Shiver isn't entirely wrong - there are endless swaths of ubiquitous SIM city towers. While there are probably close to 100 Blue Sky days, yet the endless hazy smog, street dust, and unseen particulates - especially loathsome this past December, January, and February - have finally gotten to me. I am moving to Yunnan Province, China - the land of eternal spring and blue skies all year round - initially for the quiet to write a novel, but increasingly I can't wait to leave this haze which has finally given me the never-ending Beijinger's Cough. And yet, I hope Ms. Shiver comes back to explore the gems she missed. I will come back when the authorities literally clean up their act as they did during the Olympics.

Anonymous
May 9th, 2013
6:05 AM
She's not lying - living in Beijing is like wearing very dirty glasses all the time - everything is greyish and without color. Because pollution is terrible. The more you travel outside of China the better you see it. Why should we always tell bright stories about Beijing if living here is not that bright at all. The city is fantastic thanks to the people, the food culture (well let's not get into that) and all the activities... dynamism, energy... all you want, but indeed, no colour.

Anonymous
May 9th, 2013
6:05 AM
How embarrassing for her

steve c
May 9th, 2013
5:05 AM
Yes, but waht she says is pretty much spot on.

Steve
May 9th, 2013
5:05 AM
Where is the 2000 years of culture? They have knocked it all down and are busy building dystopia. I live here, the air is getting worse and worse, and I am one of the lucky ones - I can get out

OliviaT
May 8th, 2013
3:05 PM
Ms. Shriver, even Beijingers will tell you that the air quality is shitty and the streets just as dirty. You don't have to write a pretentious article to inform anyone of that. There's a whole lot to love about China. Shame you didn't see it...

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.