Television

When Will the Beeb Wake Up?

September 2008

The most critically derided drama of the summer – quite possibly the most critically derided drama ever – was BBC 1’s Bonekickers. A team of “sexy” archaeologists (pictured below), who all look as if they are about to sleep or have just slept with each other, find that the superficially tedious business of sifting mud draws them into extraordinary adventures. It was a Robert Altman caricature made flesh: The Da Vinci Code meets Time Team, The Antiques Roadshow meets Scooby-Doo.

For once, our slobbish media grandees got their just deserts. They underestimated the intelligence of the public, and viewers fled in their millions from scripts that appeared to have been written by a teenager who learned English from the Cartoon Channel.

When the archaeologists dug up scimitars and medieval coins that seemed to show a battle between Crusaders and Saracens had taken place in – er – Somerset, one cried, “In the middle of the bloody English countryside. We have a medieval riddle to solve! So we start digging!”

“They couldn’t have been fighting Saracens here!” his colleague insisted. “That’s just nuts!”

It wasn’t, of course, and academics were soon up against a fanatically racist white Christian sect which was searching for fragments of the True Cross. “Mind-bogglingly dreadful,” said The Guardian. “Rubbish,” said The Times. The authors have the right to fail, said the man from The Independent, but “I’m not sure that it was wise of them to exercise it so vigorously”.

View Full Article
COMMENTS: 16

COMMENTS

Anonymous
September 1st, 2008
5:09 PM
Once again, Nick Cohen is bang on the money. Fantastic article.

jenny eckersley
September 1st, 2008
5:09 PM
Absolutely, totally agree with every word Jenny

The Admiral
September 2nd, 2008
10:09 AM
Nick Cohen is the only reason I think the Left might survive the next decade. It is on a suicide mission currently and unless it very urgently takes Nick Cohen's points to heart, it will self-destruct. I count, sadly, the BBC as an integral part and driving force of the Left.

riddler
September 6th, 2008
12:09 PM
Agree entirely with the article - one small point. The Kyoto protocol was adopted for use in 1997. The Clinton Administration never submitted the protocol to the Senate for ratification.

Mo Juste
September 6th, 2008
12:09 PM
An excellent piece, but a slightly clumsy sentence suggests a wrong time-frame: it was actually the US Senate under Bill Clinton that refused to ratify the Kyoto treaty - even the sainted Ted Kennedy voted against it - but Clinton signed it anyway. The global fury that erupted when the Bush administration said wouldn't ratify the treaty took no account of the US Senate's earlier rejection of same.

Jim Miller
September 6th, 2008
10:09 PM
Good piece, though like almost all British journalists, Cohen gets Kyoto wrong. The Clinton administration did sign the treaty, but never even sent it to the Senate, after 95 of 100 senators told them not to send it up without major changes. In the US, treaties are signed by a president or his representatives, but must pass the Senate with a 2/3 vote. President Bush offered, informally, to reopen the negotiations, but other leaders, notably Chirac of France preferred to have the issue.

Robert Dammers
September 7th, 2008
5:09 AM
>>Its origins lie in the refusal of the US Senate and the Bush Administration to sign the original Kyoto Treaty, which gave rise to the thoughtless narrative in contemporary Western liberalism that global warming is America’s curse on humanity.<< A comment worthy of either Bonekickers or Burn Up - which were equally nonsensical. Clinton never brought the Kyoto treaty forward for ratification to the Senate (since there had already been a vote 98-2 implying that ratification would be rejected, which Gore, the chairman of the Senate, made no effort to prevent). Gore did not attempt to bring ratification forward either. Bush merely acknowledged reality. This is not the place for a debate on the merits of Kyoto, but the idea that the rejection was as recent as Bush's time is a canard, and should be recognised as such.

jask
September 7th, 2008
8:09 AM
Well said!

Fran Waddams
September 7th, 2008
5:09 PM
I think the Left's hatred of the United States goes back farther than the actions of the current Bush Administration. They can't forget that another right wing Christian US President exposed the weakness of their beloved communism and created the conditions in which the Soviet system imploded, freeing millions from totalitarianism. With communism gone, Islamism represents the left's only hope of achieving their dream of suppressing democracy and capitalism - systems which provide people with the most freedom to live, work and believe as they choose; freedoms which leftist governments have historically denied to their wretched subjects wherever they could.

brotherjohn
September 16th, 2008
7:09 AM
Very good, and Nick Cohen and people like him with a public voice MUST keep banging on about the ludicrous situation in which white Christians continue to invent crimes for themselves of which they are not guilty. Drama reaches a wide audience, and if you keep showing the English (who, on a global scale, are actually quite nice) as perpetrators of crimes against humanity then the drip, drip effect will mean that we, and everyone one who already hates us, will believe it and hate us even more. And it just ain't true. This is already causing massive social/cultural problems in Britain, and our self-hatred - compounded by ludicrous BBC dramas and biased C4 documentaries - will destroy us in the end.

Anonymous
September 16th, 2008
7:09 AM
Yes Bonekickers was awful. When did you last see a black archaeologist? And two out of a team of four? In a drama about white on black racism? The BBC should be prosecuted for encouraging racial hatred.

Runtgen
September 19th, 2008
2:09 AM
The censorship and leanings of the BBC are stifling creativity and suffocating freedom of expression. Dennis Potter would have been rejected by today's BBC.

John Linden Powell
September 19th, 2008
10:09 PM
Just stop watching TV.That will improve your life and temper,and save your mind from flaccid nonsense.

Mehdi
September 22nd, 2008
3:09 AM
As much as I detest the American Molla BHO - Nick's reason for his election is a sensible one. However, I am afraid that he (and us) will be disappointed to see it makes no difference in the behaviour of the post-left.

Gennith
September 22nd, 2008
12:09 PM
I am proud to live in a country where drooling socialists are free to explore the depths of their talent. I just resent being forcibly taxed to pay for them.

Heavy Hitta
October 13th, 2008
1:10 AM
I consider myself of the left but Nick Cohen is bang on the money (although I disagreed with his support for the war in Iraq) I have anti globalist/anti fascist friends who's thinking is so muddled it's enough to make you're eyes itch. "911 was an inside job but it was also blowback for the Wests evil imperialism" "America and the world is run by evil corporations and it's foreign policy is all about oil" "America and the world is run by the Jews who manufacture consent by dominating the media and control the economies of the world by owning all the banks" "It's not racist to believe in a Jewish conspiracy, it is racist to criticise anything to do with Islam" "It's left wing to support the movements of the far right as long as they are anti American" "It's right wing to support the unions in Iran against the far right theocratic dictators in Tehran" "Hamas are not racist they are legitimate freedom fighters" "Salman Rushdie and Ayaan Hirsi Ali are racists" "As long as America opposes the tyranny in Sudan we will refuse to call for intervention" "The real oppression and tyranny comes from cartoonists in Denmark" The left has lost it's mind and it's having a nervous breakdown but to say as much makes you a neocon racist. The world is upside down!!

POST A COMMENT

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.