You are here:   Columns >  The Outsider's Diary >
 
June 2008

The foreign affairs spokesman for Spain’s opposition Partido Popular, Gustavo de Aristegui received death threats through encrypted Saudi websites in 2006; now he lives with a security detail. The same year the Turkish-born German MP Ekin Deligoz was put under police protection when her life was repeatedly threatened for criticising the wearing of the headscarf.

The predominance of Muslims and former Muslims on the front line here is no accident. The Zaire-born Swedish integration minister, Nyamko Sabuni, has been under police protection since speaking out against female genital mutilation and honour killings. As with the cases of Hirsi Ali and Rushdie, it is when someone “from their own side” speaks out that hatred spills over into violence.

So there are obvious choices to make. Will we quietly accept that we live de facto under some of the strictest laws of the sharia? Or will more public figures do Islam the decency of giving it the same place as other ideas in our culture? A place where films are made, books and articles written, cartoons cartooned and religious and political opinions voiced which tell truths, lambast, lampoon and offend, but which afford Islam the dignity of equality.

The BBC and many other media have been cowed. Some artists have finally had the courage to admit they are scared. But we need them to do better than that. We need people with a voice to show that they aren’t scared. Pace the notably unfunny Khomeini, there are lots of jokes in Islam. And that is the sound we should hear — the raucous noise of unfettered debate, laughter and often inevitable offence. Intimidation has been very successful in preventing that offence, and in the process Muslims have been cocooned and the most reactionary versions of their religion accepted as the norm. The antidote is not concession, flattery or silence. The answer is noise.

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
Jim West
July 15th, 2008
12:07 AM
Brilliant. And an essay very much in need of wide attention.

Edward Gregson-Williams
June 11th, 2008
7:06 PM
Fantastic article, Douglas. If I may add, some would label brave voices (like Wilders) as 'Islamophobic'; however a phobia would suggest that there is something irrational about a fear of having ones throat cut in the name of an ideology. I find it deeply ironic that Europe insists upon tolerating the intolerant - some people are in dire need of a sense of humour. The voice of the voiceless must be heard.

Alcuin
June 11th, 2008
7:06 PM
Quite right. What Islam fears more than anything else is satire, and it is ripe for it.

Anonymous
June 6th, 2008
2:06 AM
Excellent, excellent article - very relevant since shock artist Dino Chapman just said in an interview that the only subject he would not touch was Islam. He lacked even the courage to say what is patently obvious - he is scared. No, instead he wittered on about how its because Muslims are treated so terribly unfairly in the UK. Pathetic.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.