You are here:   Civilisation >  Theatre > Terrible Home Truths
 

This isn't the only tragedy hanging over the family. Joe's business partner is in prison, disgraced, for knowingly supplying faulty cylinder heads from Joe's factory to US Air Force planes, with the result that 21 young wartime pilots crashed to their deaths. Joe has always denied any part in it and has escaped jail, but there are doubts about his account. Along with his devoted wife and son, Joe is gradually forced to recognise some terrible truths. 

Joe's overriding interest in life is his family, particularly his sons. His narrow devotion to them has been both motive and excuse for everything he has done. Miller made it clear in his introduction to his collected plays that All My Sons is in part about the wider responsibility people have to the world beyond their own back porch. Joe's problem is that he cannot see his own connection to society beyond his own backyard. But I find that unconvincing. It doesn't demand any understanding of a wider society to know that sending boys to their deaths to avoid a commercial loss, and then letting another man take the blame is wrong even by the most parochial of standards. 

What is more interesting and central to the play is the way that the main characters manage to deceive themselves, at least partly — another theme with contemporary political resonance. "You have such a talent for ignoring things," Chris says to his mother but it seems he shares it. And as a neighbour remarks, living with something terrible requires a certain talent for lying. Evasion, fabulation, forgetting, lying — these are unstable, intermittent devices and Suchet shows with brilliantly subtle transformations the many unstable changes of mood that Joe goes through. He even seems to change physically, to grow, shrink and age through Joe's reluctant progress towards the punishing truth. 

A talent for ignoring things and for lying is central to Simon Gray's play at the Donmar Warehouse, The Late Middle Classes. This is its London première, though it was first produced in Watford in 1999. Like All My Sons, it is set soon after the Second World War, but in an England where there is still food rationing. Charles is a typically lower-upper-middle-class Englishman, an inhibited pathologist given to bitter witticisms who is glad that at least his patients don't talk to him. His snobbish wife Celia is bored and discontented. Forced to humiliate herself socially in the pursuit of company and scarce fresh eggs, she consoles herself with gin, cigarettes and tennis, ignoring her son apart from fitful emotional blackmail. 

Holliday, their son (who shares his name with Simon Gray) , is articulate and talented. They allow him to take piano lessons at the house of his besotted music teacher and his neurotic, Viennese émigré mother, whose complicity Holly breezily ignores. Caught at the edge of adolescence between the indifference of his parents and the excessive interest of Mr Brownlow, Holly negotiates the complications of his life with a vulnerable, heartbreaking sophistication. Laurence Belcher (one of three boys playing the role) is quite exceptional; indeed, he steals the show. Gray's admirers should not miss this overdue London production of the play, but they will have to admit that, for all its wit, perception and black comedy, it is by his standards rather slow and slight. 

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.