You are here:   Civilisation >  Critique > The Drumming of an Army
 


It never rains: Brisbane, January 2011 

Poetry, said Auden, makes nothing happen. Usually it doesn't, but sometimes a poem gets quoted in a national argument because everybody knows it, or at least part of it, and for the occasion a few lines of familiar poetry suddenly seem the best way of summing up a viewpoint. Just such an occasion has occurred recently in Australia.  By the time the heavy rains first hit Queensland early this year, the theory of Catastrophic Anthropogenic Global Warming (CAGW, to borrow the unlovely acronym) was ceasing to exercise unquestioned thrall in the minds of Australia's progressive voters. But spokespersons for the Green party clung on to it, encouraged by the fact that the theory, in its Climate Change form, was readily applicable to any circumstances.  

Before the floods, proponents of the CAGW view had argued that there would never be enough rain again, because of Climate Change. When it became clear that there might be more than enough rain, the view was adapted: the floods, too, were the result of Climate Change. In other words, they were something unprecedented. Those opposing this view — those who believed that in Australia nothing could be less unprecedented than a flood unless it was a drought — took to quoting Dorothea Mackellar's poem "My Country", which until recently every Australian youngster was obliged to hear recited in school. In my day we sometimes had to recite it ourselves, and weren't allowed to go home until we had given evidence that we could remember at least the first four lines of the second stanza, which runs like this. 

I love a sunburnt country,
A land of sweeping plains,
Of ragged mountain ranges,
Of droughts and flooding rains.
I love her far horizons,
I love her jewel-sea,
Her beauty and her terror —
The wide brown land for me.

The first four lines of the stanza are the bit that everybody knows, partly because they are so addictively crafted, and partly because they fit the national experience of what Australia's geography and climate are actually like. In any household, the seniors (known in Australia as "the wrinklies") remember the droughts and the flooding rains of their childhood. I myself remember the Maitland floods of the early 1950s. The whole of the central seaboard of New South Wales was under water. I can remember rain you couldn't see through: right there in my southern suburb of Sydney, the creek flooded the park, and the lake in the park spilled into the bottom of our street, prompting the construction of a galvanised iron canoe in which three of us sailed to what would have been certain death if the contraption had floated for more than a few seconds.  

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
Anonymous GeeGee
March 9th, 2011
4:03 PM
Oh,my! All the self important 'scientists' rubbishing Clive James excellent article. As far as I can see, all he is saying is that despite the present preoccupation with climate change, it has and always will be changing and it is better to take sensible, common sense precautions based on historical knowledge (aided by poetry of course!)Good on yer, cobber!

IAN HILLIAR
March 9th, 2011
7:03 AM
It is always fun to read Clives erudite comments ,and of course even more so when he pokes fun at people like Tim Flannery and ,of course, Clive Hamilton. The one thing these people really cant stand is being laughed at. Laughter is our greatest weapon against self important politicians and self appointed "public intellectuals", as they have no real sense of humour, only a sense of their own importance.

Paul
March 8th, 2011
1:03 PM
Enjoyable read, thanks, Clive. Also enjoyed the hilarious comments from the tofu eating, turbine hugging brigade.No need for you to respond to their barbs about "facts", they have yet to provide any themselves.

Paul A
March 8th, 2011
11:03 AM
Dear Clive Having heard and read your previous pronouncements on the topic of climate change I have concluded that there is only a small chance that you will ever understand the scientific basis of climate change, or the reason the tiny minority of scientists who disagree with the mainstream are very likely to remain a tiny minority. What disappoints me now is that the language you use here. You use the "unlovely acronym" CAGW (an initialisation by the way, not an acronym), a term you won’t find in any scientific literature. You also use the unlovely term "warmist". These are linguistic constructs of ideologues and dissemblers of science whose aim is to dumb-down public debate. They do for the public understanding of science what a Gaddafi speech does for the hopes and aspirations of Libyan youth. As a man of letters this language ought to ring alarm bells in you. Instead you seem to have immersed yourself in it, and uncritically regurgitate it here. As a former admirer, and I am extremely disappointed.

Lazal
March 7th, 2011
11:03 PM
The planet's climate scientists (with exception of a literal handful, usually sponsored by the fossil corporations) are all telling us climate change is happening, it is caused by human activity and we need to act to prevent very bad things happening. The recent floods are just a taster. But we can ignore them because someone found a poem that says there have been floods in the past. Throw in a bit of "common sense" and - bingo! All those satellites, ice cores, temperature records and PhDs making sense of them are wrong. Personally, I think doctors are overrated as well. There's nothing you can't cure with a few leeches.

nicholas tesdorf
March 7th, 2011
10:03 PM
Clive shows that Poetry is more scientific than the 'science' from the IPCC. It will last a good deal longer too.

Tom Harris
March 7th, 2011
10:03 PM
Very interesting article. I especially like the conclusion and will highlight that on our home page. Of course climate varies on all times scales and we had better adapt or die. The idea that we can stop these natural cycles is irrational and we need to say this at every opportunity, politically correct or not. Tom Harris, B. Eng., M. Eng. (Mech.) Executive Director International Climate Science Coalition (ICSC) P.O. Box 23013 Ottawa, Ontario K2A 4E2 Canada http://www.climatescienceinternational.org

V. infernalis
March 7th, 2011
8:03 AM
Well, since we're arguing against facts using prose, allow me to try my hand: "Life's but a walking shadow, a poor player That struts and frets his hour upon the stage And then is heard no more: it is a tale Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, Signifying nothing." No bonus points for guessing who the idiot is.

Diane Audrey Wallis
March 7th, 2011
8:03 AM
I always thought it was "rugged mountain ranges" – thanks for that – ragged not rugged. I too remember the Maitland floods and my late father-in-law recalled a Sydney summer (maybe before WWII) when it rained every weekend and all the little beach-side kiosks selling ice-creams went broke. Tricky old place Australia.

John Frankis
March 7th, 2011
5:03 AM
Quite right Clive, you are indeed the scientist of our dreams not a crusty old windbag who'd ruin a great poem by talking his presumptuous nonsense all over and around it.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.