You are here:   Features > The Establishment Is In Denial — Yet Again
 
Whenever that key issue of Muslim demographics does bubble up in our country it is always shut down with the same fervour and pique. Whenever it is reported that Mohammed was the most popular name for new-born British boys each year the story is dismissed on some technicality. Too many variants of the name were included or not enough variants was usually the mask for the real response which was, “Shut up.” When, in 2015, Mohammed became unarguably the most popular boy’s name in Britain the only acceptable response suddenly turned into: “So what. That’s cool.” But underneath this the public, like the present generation of politicians, knows that it is not entirely cool. Or at least not something without significant ramifications.

Predictions are a dangerous thing. But allow me to make one. Ten years ago nobody but a few of us crazy right-wing nut-jobs wanted to mention anything critical about Saudi Arabia or Iran, Wahhabism or Khomeinism. And nobody but nobody wanted to say anything about Islam other than that it was an obviously and demonstrably peaceful religion.

All this, I notice, has recently begun to change somewhat. Today you can turn on the television any day and see people talking about all these things who ten years ago were busily calling everyone who did so a racist. Those who were here first shall get no apology and should expect none. It was all too predictable.

But perhaps it gives me the right to make another prediction. Which is that at some point in the next ten years it will be possible to say, while not being regarded as a right-wing maniac, that the beliefs of the people in a country and the number of people with those beliefs will influence the make-up, behaviour and actions of that country.

Currently we are in one of our interim periods of denial. The care being taken to change the name by which we call IS is just one demonstration of this. Such attempts to decouple the activities of IS from the beliefs of Islam as a whole are principally being done for a domestic audience, not to woo away the hordes of IS fighters already in Syria and Iraq. But why might we think the domestic audience needs such placating?

One reason is the facts. In a poll carried out by the BBC after the Charlie Hebdo attack last January, 27 per cent of British Muslims polled said they had “some sympathy” for the motives behind the Paris attacks. In the wake of the November attacks in Paris, the Sun carried out a poll whose findings claimed that one in five British Muslims has “sympathy for ISIS”. This poll was subjected to justified scrutiny, for not least among the poll’s flaws was that the questions related to attitudes towards those who go out to fight in Syria. A proportion of those who expressed support for these may well have been thinking of those who go out to fight with other factions in Syria and even those who go out to fight against IS with Kurdish groups among others.

But the response to the Sun poll was in fact the same response that now comes after any and all such negative stories. Far more energy is expended refuting the story than in addressing a legitimate problem. Because, although one in five British Muslims don’t sympathise with IS, quite a number clearly do. But this is a pattern. After last January’s terror attacks the attention of European publics and governments turned for a week by a claim about “no-go zones” made by a Fox News guest expert. So much time was spent ridiculing Fox News that nobody had much time to consider whether Europe did have no-go zones. We learned again in November that it did — in France, Belgium, Sweden and elsewhere across Europe. But these are not the stories we want to hear. And so we find new ones.

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
Peter from scotland
January 20th, 2016
7:01 PM
clear thinking and honesty about the most important issue of our time. It is depressing and worrying that so few in the media and government seem to see what is in front of them or distract themselves with trivia and made up stories that make them feel better. I agree about the SNP and parochialism- the issues seems too big for them.

Jonathan G
January 10th, 2016
3:01 AM
The most disgusting thing about the #illridewithyou hashtag that 'went viral' during the Sydney Seige at the Lindt cafe was that this occurred *during* the seige. This was while the hostages had to hold the Shahada flag up to the window while the maniac swung his gun around threatening them. *Perhaps* there was a good sentiment about the hashtag when used in a specific context, but I think the 'viral' spreading of it had a nasty undertone of a) the *real* victimes here are Muslims in Australia, not the people with a gun to their head; and b) Australians are on the verge of carrying out a pogrom at a moments notice. As it happened, my brother's boyfriend - a Singaporean -ethnically Arab- Muslim (yes, gay Muslims exist, but only in private) was due to come over to my family dinner the following day. I was worried about some sort of backlash and that he (and my brother) could be attacked on public transport - mainly because of his obviously Arab appearance and obvious homosexual campness. But I'm certain that the #illridewithyou did not extend to him. It's not about the protection of vulnerable people, it's more of a Twitterati demonstration of guilt, self-hatred, and a statement of one's own progressive-multiculturalism and solidarity with 'oppressed' peoples.

Anonymous
December 27th, 2015
6:12 PM
The problem is worse than even Murray realises. He too is prone to making apologetic statements when he's outnumbered by lefties on a TV studio couch. He also makes the mistake of banking on our intellects waking up to the kumbaya lemon the Left have sold us for decades. Political correctness has stripped us of critical faculty upon which all our prior success was based. It's not our intellects that will power a fightback to islamisation, it's our instincts that will save us.

Karma
December 27th, 2015
1:12 PM
An excellent, well reasoned article. Two things spring to mind, there are many people who hope the problem will go away if we in the west stop fighting back and declare ourselves to be terrible and admit our guilt - it won't happen, the Islamic terrorists will just carry on with their aim to destroy western culture. Second, until western governments recognise we will have to fight their beliefs at home, we will remain vulnerable to constant attacks.

Isaac Brajtman
December 26th, 2015
11:12 AM
Please send this article to all the major press in every country,then maybe THE PEOPLE will wake up. In Israel the Palestinian (Moslem) leaders encourage stabbing and crashing cars into civilians. When they are shot the press reports " a Palestinian was killed by Israeli soldiers or police", and then the statement "after he stabbed 2 or 3 civilians " Something radical needs to be done on university campuses, were young students are attracted to extreme left views and in many cases attacking those who don't agree with them It has been said that if you are not a socialist when you are 20 , you have no heart. If you are still a socialist when you are 50, you have no brain

George Layne
December 21st, 2015
7:12 PM
impeccable analysis Douglas! I was unaware that the stories regarding the woman taking off her headscarf and the security guard were fabrications. I had - as many people did - noticed the tendency for mainstream media after such atrocities to latch on to stories that show Muslim's in a good light. The fact that these stories were false shows a fanatical desperation to achieve this. I'm also glad you noticed the mass hysteria in and out of parliament regarding the airstrikes. I know a guy who said he was so appalled by the governments decision to 'bomb civilians' as he stated, that he was going to leave England! His reaction was not only over-the-top, but his analysis of the situation was completely wrong! Unfortunately, he is typical of people on the left at the moment. Keep up the good work!

Anonymous
December 21st, 2015
1:12 PM
Such an enlightened thinker, such a gifted writer Mr Murray is. Beautifully phrased article, such gripping and shattering structure when you read through the text, how you're just struck by one despairing fact after another, like ominous pearls on a sting crafted by an insightful Cassandra, that if it wasn't the absurd and despondent reality we are amidst, at this very moment, today, one could take Mr. Murray's talented reporting and wording for an excerpt from a tragic novel about decline and fall; the unwillingness to do anything, stand for anything; a nation, a country, a culture not defeated but dispirited; no longer capable or up for it. This goes for the rest of Europe and Western civilization as well. Look at Canada. Look at Sweden. I find it odd wanting to praise Mr Murray for his obvious talent and inexplicable appreciated voice to a great deal of people, both in writing and in speech, I find it odd wanting to do that because your mind looks for superlatives and adjectives in the box of beauty, which seems silly constructing, when in fact you've just read an article about our reality, that made one feel a Kafkaesque impotence, a speechlessness, as we all are lead - willfully or forced - on our way to dire times ahead of us.

Aussie
December 21st, 2015
12:12 PM
Thanks Douglas. I first heard of you last week while listening to a podcast by Sam Harris. Great article and good point regarding the wordplay. We must watch what we say, we don't want to offend the Muslims and we certainly don't want to put them all in the same basket as the Islamic terrorists. Even though, mind you, the Islamic terrorists not only put all non-Muslims and even other Muslims in the same basket but then go about slaughtering them. But no, don't blame Muslims or Islam about that. Political correctness is a useless waste of time and actually a serious hindrance when dealing with such a miserable foe.

Twarticus
December 21st, 2015
12:12 PM
As always, thought-provoking stuff from DM. But are insightful descriptions of what we appear to be/do, enough? Given that current policy may be wrong, and I believe it is, what than might be better. Can Douglas provide any thoughts on what remedies might be available? If we do need a map to make our way out of this situation - where is it?

Evad666
December 21st, 2015
7:12 AM
Currently we have 5177 reported white and Sikh underage victims of Muslim abusers here in the UK spread across 40 English towns and cities. The Political class choose to ignore that and we permit it at our peril.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.