Standpoint Blogs
Michael Burleigh
Grizzly Bears Dance
Art of Seduction
This detailed investigation by CNN into the inner workings of a Belgium based Al Qaeda linked cell with connections to the Heathrow liquid bomb plotters is worth reading to the very end. The defence lawyer's argument that one of the suspects talked tough on a jihadist website to 're-seduce' an old flame sounds depressingly plausible- revealing as much about her as him.
Meanwhile, any joy I felt yesterday about the- possible deportation of Abu Qatada - had been dispelled by the news in today's papers that he and his comrades are claiming compensation for false imprisonment, which it seems, they are likely to get.
Of course, it is really the lawyers representing them who are, so to speak, taking the piss, or rather the massed lawyers in our Parliament who inflicted such a system on this country. If the law changed, the lawyers and judges would have to implement it.
An editorial in today's Times briefly indicated that none of this farce need have happened since many of our European partners- who also signed into the European Human Rights Convention, such as France, simply deported their detainees anyway. Why is France, the country that pioneered human rights, and which has a powerful legal profession, somehow able to avoid this nonsense?
President for Life
And its Goodbye to him, almost
The Law Lords have finally granted the Home Secretary leave to deport Abu Quatada to Jordan (see Daily Mail). He was granted asylum here fifteen years ago after arriving on a false passport, repaying our hospitality by becoming Bin Laden's top man in Europe. Oh and he and his family cost us £50,000 a year in welfare payments when the government doesn't manage to keep him in prison.
But don't hold your breath. Even as the Lords delivered their judgement, Qatada's human rights lawyers were preparing an appeal to the Court of European Rights, which will enable him to cling on the British door frame for another couple of years.
Jihad Night
I watched the C4 News report on Somali jihadists so I missed the parallel Panorama on how British counter-terrorism policy may be taking a more hawkish turn. Let's keep our fingers crossed. Actually, the C4 news item had its own moments.
I had not realised there are 250,000 Somalis in this country, although I am now interested in how Ealing's "Mogadishu Mile" came about. I knew about Woolwich, but Ealing? The programme was triggered by news that an Oxford Brookes University dropout had killed himself, and a couple of dozen Ethiopian peace keepers, in a suicide bomb attack at home (home being Somalia rather than Ealing). There he was, jabbing his bony finger in his suicide video testament, a vision I will always associate with these times.
Several speakers rather breezily assured us that it was unlikely that the 60 or 70 Somalis going on jihad 'at home' might be redirected to blow us up in Britain. This line was picked up by Jon Snow in the studio discussion afterwards. Actually, there is no reason why Somalis should be less prone to do what Anglo-Pakistani jihadists have done already if someone 'at home' decides they should commit atrocities here.
The Panorama programme showed several self-styled clerics insisting that God's law trumped man's laws, and that democracy was anti-Islamic too. They had nasty things to say about gays too, which really got the BBC's man's goat. His programme unpicked the various strands of the government's counter-terrorism policy: PREVENT, CONTEST, PURSUE, while mentioning how much money individual so-called community leaders rake in for devising de-radicalisation programmes or theological denunciations of violent interpretations of jihad. A £100,000 here, £180,000 there.......of our money, on top of the £100,000s councils already spill out for things like translations of official documents, surely a task the 'communities' could pay for themselves?
Meanwhile, later at night Newsnight surpassed itself by devoting two reports to telling us how nice Iran and Venezuela's rulers really are. The fact that Chavez has appointed himself president until about 2030 didn't seem to unduly distress Gavin Esler, while Fatty Simpson (all nostagia for when he'd covered the Shah's overthrow) admired little Iranian boys' funky hair........until a secret policeman told him the Islamic Revolution's anniversary was no laughing matter.
Puff of Smoke
They are coming, and they may be moral
Today's Times gives us a glimpse into something I have long felt was coming: robot warriors, one of the few commercial fields I would have thought was a good investment for those with any money left. The West's reluctance to take large numbers of military casualties will surely mean the advent of robot soldiers as well as driverless vehicles and more pilotless aircraft.
One obvious advantage, that goes unmentioned in this article, is that robots have no emotions and hence are unlikely to engage in the rage/revenge killings that usually occur after a unit has taken casualties. Presumably robots will also be able to calculate a non-lethal shot than a human who is trained to hit the largest target area in the chest? Advanced artillery systems already calculate potential collateral damage and lock down so as to make them inoperable if the levels are too high. Anyway, this is the future, and it may work.
A gem by Roger Scruton
Game's Up
One of my favourite political commentators, Iain Martin, explains why the game is up for this Labour government.
He's right about their reluctance to appear on programmes like Any Questions or Question Time. Last night, the normally fluent Liam Byrne was thrown off stride by Dimbleby and never recovered, despite the Tory spokesperson being well this side of hopeless. The studio audiences are also starting to laugh at whatever government ministers say, always a very bad sign, as is their reduction to nothing more than mere ambition, which was all I saw in Byrne's smirking face.
More on Afghanistan
Donnizetti?
The Gentle Sex?
Today's Mail has an interesting piece on a new German book about women under the Nazis.
When I was younger there used to be a sort of obligatory 'women's corner' in each book of essays on Nazism; mea culpa since I once commissioned Jill Stephenson to write such a piece. I included a lot of material about nurses and doctors in my Death and Deliverance: Euthanasia in Germany 1900-45. I guess both Downfall and The Reader has made the subject topical.
This book seems to raise a lot of interesting questions, although it should be noted that men were just as susceptible to mass hysteria as women. I hadn't realised that the Einsatzgruppen took along their own 'Schreibkraefte' and must check that out. Surely men could type?
Travel Bans
The Dutch Foreign Minister has complained to Boy Miliband about the Home Secretary's 'noteworthy' decision to deny entry tomorrow to Geert Wilders after one Muslim Labour peer warned about mob disorder in the precincts of Westminster.
Apparently antagonising a country with which we have close historical and cultural ties is OK, if such a gesture appeases the Muslim minority, who are trying to shape our licensed discourse (through libel actions and threats of violence) as well as our banking, legal system, and foreign policy.
I hope Britain's human rights lawyers will rush to take up Mr Wilders's case with the alacrity with which they seek to repatriate suspected terrorists and failed asylum seekers from Guantanamo Bay, or have sought to frustrate the extradition of Abu Hamza to the US. Somehow I suspect this is not going to happen.
While we are about incitement to inter-communal hatred, I would have thought that this week's manipulative Panorama about Gaza was a pretty good example of the phenomenon, certainly judging from the comments made about it to me by various Muslim shopkeepers who saw it, all of whom duly took away the impression of Jews as child-murderers.
The BBC has a go at Egypt
The Left Oxygenates Itself (Again)
I don't normally pay any attention to Ed Balls, but something he insinuated in the Telegraph caught my eye. He didn't need to explicitly mention Facism (rise of) since the BBC and trades unions have done that for him. Their ears are permanently glued to the ground to detect the jackboots coming- all part of their pathological fear of the working classes who routinely defect direct from Labour to the BNP.
As an historian I also wondered about how the Depression "caused" Fascism. If my memory serves, the Fascists were founded in Milan in 1919, and were in power in Rome by 1922, long before the Depression. The mutilated victory in 1918 and the gestural antics of the Communists had rather a lot to to with this. Likewise, it was defeat in WW1, and the hyper-inflation of the early 1920s, which shattered the German political system, propelling middle class voters towards the Nazis. Rather a lot of studies have shown that the unemployed did not tend to vote for them when they voted at all. Something does not quite ring true with what Balls is insinuating.
Of course there is a perfectly respectable alternative to this fag end Labour government, and the (non-existent "threat" of Fascism). It is called the Conservative Party. They should be going to great lengths to expose how Labour is trying to re-oxygenate itself by conjuring Fascist shadows on the wall, a tactic I have heard from Blears, Blunkett, and now Balls, which suggests it is being cynically orchestrated.
I also wonder why no one seems willing to concede that "Fascists" can undergo the same sort of political evolutions that Communists have undergone in the last forty years? Are they uniquely stuck in a time warp? Just on logical grounds I find that implausible- although I am sure there are those who study it. I'd be curious to know.
Thinking Caps On
A comment piece in today's Times exemplifies much of what's wrong about the current trans-Atlantic "debate" about Afghanistan.
The author, a former army officer with experience a long time ago in Northern Ireland, goes through the usual routine about how that analogy is inappropriate (agreed, so what does he bring to the table?) before settling down to discuss NATO's presence in purely military terms. Factors like national will are assumed in a manner I find irritating, just as I find it incredible that Brown will roll over to send the extra troops the US requires without a proper debate.
Elsewhere I noticed a piece in the FT by Anatol Lieven which recommended we withdraw, leaving special forces to aid bombers to destroy any incipient signs of al Qaeda opening pre-9/11 style training camps. Of course, that strategy would have our human rights regiment up in arms the moment some innocent civilian was killed. We've already had Patrick "Holy Joe" Mercer (another ex-soldier with NI experience) protesting when a US drone apparently zapped Rashid Rauf, a (fugitive) British citizen who's human rights were transgressed. Oh dearie me.
"Debate" across the ocean is not much better. A recent article I read recommends sending leaders of the Anbar Awakening to Afghanistan to try to create something similar there. Otherwise, there is a lot of muttering about the inadequacies of the Karzai government, and the length of time it has taken to recruit even 70,000 men to the Afghan National Army. The Iraqi National Army has recruited half a million men over the same period. The Russians, and their clients in the Stans, are cutting up rough about alternative supply routes since the Taliban succeeded in interdicting the Khyber Pass road.
We are told that Afghanistan will require a 30 to 50 year committment, which takes it way beyond my lifetime, or that of any politician currently on the scene. One might have thought this was a golden opportunity, or rather a matter of urgent necessity, for the Conservatives to have a wide-ranging debate about what the West's options really are, bearing in mind that "Afpak" is one of the main sources of the terrorism we have seen already.
Of course, we won't see such a debate because the Tory 'securocrats' are locked into the same mindset as the author of the Times piece. I don't know what an alternative policy might look like, given that the Islamist problem spans the Afpak border. But if I was the one of those who for the next 30 to 50 years had to get up in the Commons to record the names of the dead, I'd be looking into this more imaginatively than seems to be happening at present. I'd start off by involving all the neighbours, for without the involvement of Iran and India, as well as Pakistan, this is going to be a supra-generational nightmare.
Saving the world, leading the world
I wonder whether our Prime Minister believes what he says after reading this on the BBC's news website. This is clearly not a slip of the tongue like the saving the world stuff, but an example of British boosterism at its worst.
As Chancellor of the Exchequer Brown encouraged the casino conditions that are now 'angering' him. He is not 'leading the world' on this one- if he was, he'd be doing what the US does, which is have the FBI trawl through the affairs of some of these bankers in the likelihood of discovering some irregularity which would land them in Chokey for a very long time. That would concentrate their minds powerfully. As for the bankers, their veiled threat to move elsewhere is risible since there are no jobs for any of them, except possibly in the Far East.
An offer
Apparently Home Secretary Jacqui Smith claims a lot of money (more than the national average wage) for lodging three or four nights a week with her sister in London. Very nobly she's contributing to the household budget. This is causing a fuss among pesky journalists who don't quite see things her way.
I have some solutions. She can either stay here for half the price, and I'll chuck in some free tutorials on terrorism with the boiled eggs, or, she can double up with the policemen guarding one of her Cabinet colleagues who sit in a quite spacious garage. That way she gets a bed and protection in one, and gets to learn about policing from the 'coal face'.
The New Lexicon
A friend used a word I had never heard of: "disintermediated".
Apparently a lot of middle men are going to find themselves superfluous to requirements, which is what disintermediate means.
It reminds me of the Daleks. Instead of 'exterminate', 'exterminate' substitute 'disintermediate', 'disintermediate' and you'll see what I mean.
Double Standards
Tim Marshall of Sky has an interesting counterfactual about why the baying mob denouncing Israel- especially the infantilised mob that teaches or studies in our so-called "world class" universities - don't seem to have noticed the parallel anti-terrorist operation in Sri Lanka.
This does not seem to excite their imagination in quite the same way; perhaps because beneath that anger about dying Palestinian children- so helpfully rushed up to Hamas cameramen - lie deep seated collective myths about Jews as child-murderers? A thousand years or more of 'acculturation' probably leaves all sorts of undetectable effects. Discuss. I also wonder whether fear plays its part, the fear that underlay the 'realism' of appeasement in the 1930s? If only those pesky Jews in Israel and their vociferous supporters in the West would disappear, then those fundamentally peace-loving Muslims would leave us alone and all would be well? Frederick Raphael calls this the unfinished business of the Holocaust syndrome.
One way the West can immediately correct this- as recommended in today's Observer, my paper of choice nowadays - is for NATO to issue nuclear guarantees to several of the Sunni states which may feel inclined to proliferate if Iran succeeds, as I feel it will, in acquiring a nuclear weapon. China and Russia, the author suggests, could guarantee them too. There seems little point in seeking tougher sanctions - which Germany and Russia will flout under their newfound Rapallo spirit of gaseous understanding - if there is also no big stick hovering in the background. Such a guarantee would show Tehran we really mean business and are not afraid to countenance Iran's complete annihilation, as opposed to whatever pin pricks the Israeli air force might deal to its bomb programme. You won't hear many protests around the Arab world about that. Mr Ahmadinejad may view the apocalypse with equanimity; the savvier clerics will protect the Revolution at his expense.
The Plot Thickens
As I indicated a day or two ago, something is not straight about the story Miliband is telling about US intelligence, British courts, and Binyam Mohammed. Coverage in today's papers is pretty weak, especially apologias written by Miliband's mates, except for this piece in the Sunday Telegraph.
The authors might have mentioned that CIA field operatives routinely take out legal indemnity insurance, which I suspect is not the case with their colleagues here. So far.
Presumably the lawyers trying to get Mr Mohammed back into the UK- despite his being a failed Ethiopian asylum clainmant who was picked up in Pakistan using a fake passport - are also the ones lobbying Baroness Scotland to investigate this can of worms?
And how did we arrive at a position where the greatest external threat to our closest ally comes from the Islamists we have allowed to multiply in our midst? That's the real scandal that needs to be addressed.
A Really Brilliant Book
Tortuous Explanations
The boy Foreign Secretary and the liberal judges seem not to have got their story straight about the US government pressurising our courts not to reveal intelligence materials that allegedly derive from torture.
The reality is easy to imagine. Call from King Charles Street to Virginia: 'Langley, we have a problem' /'Yeh?'/'Some human rights lawyers and judges are poking into our intelligence agencies being complicit in torture, could you help us out here by saying you refuse to put your intelligence material in the public domain?' /'Why?' 'Because if you don't we'll deny you access to data on all those Anglo-Pakistanis who, as you know, ARE THE MAIN TERRORIST THREAT TO THE USA'. That's the reality I suspect Miliband doesn't want discussed in open court, not all this blather about the US pressuring the British.
The BBC BECOMES THE STORY AGAIN
Today's Mail editorial encapsulates everything I think about the BBC. There are also two excellent comment pieces by Stephen Glover and Melanie Phillips in the same paper today.
Carol Thatcher interviewed me about twenty years ago for some local radio station. She was nice, jolly, unpretentious, and I noted, rather sad. Maybe she wasn't having a great day. I've never seen her since.
The BBC offends me virtually every day with its bumptious presenters; unfunny comedians; and ingrained Left-wing current affairs/news bias. Worse, we have to pay £130 a year to have this travesty of everything we believe in, simply in order to own a TV set on which we mainly watch Channel 5. I loath its awful low grade smugness- exemplified by the ubiquity of the likes of Shami Chakrabati, Helena Kennedy, Philippe Sands et al- and the relentless references on its arts programming to award-winning, prize-winning (load of crap).
Of all the things to get worked up about, Thatcher using the expression 'gollywog' comes low down on my list. High on it, by contrast, would be anyone exploiting a private conversation to snitch on someone with a view to ruining their livelihood, something I last saw in the film 'Lives of Others' although I'm familiar with the practice from academe where it is used all the time. Listening to a member of the BBC nomeklatura on Radio 4 this morning, justifying Thatcher being sacked, the penny really dropped about the "culture" of this awful organisation.
As the BBC yet again becomes its own story, I hope the Conservatives will have the guts to take this over mighty subject not only down, but cut into small saleable pieces, when they replace this fag-end Labour government in the foreseeable future. The fact that I like Jazz Record Requests, or that others claim to enjoy Gardeners' World, is neither here nor there- I'll gladly pay a small subscription to hear the former.
A long lunch with Freddie Raphael, mainly devoted to discussing The Reader. His conversation sparkles, switching from French and Latin back into English in various accents. I have a sore throat from too much shouting at the TV, so his rapier flashed at a frog that could merely croak. He combines deep learning, especially about the Classics, with a great sense of humour- rich tales of Hollywood. Sometimes life feels great- strolling down to Hyde Park with him after a four hour pow wow was one of those moments.
Rape and Suicide Bombers
In Blood and Rage I wrote about the motives of (captured) female suicide bombers in Palestine. They included women who had been groomed so as to nullify some perceived slur on their honour, including a woman who was encouraged to kill herself by her husband after he had divorced her and moved a younger replacement into the family home. Today's Times has a truly shocking report from Iraq about some harridan who has persuaded rape victims to blow themselves up, including some who's rape she organised. I am generally against the death penalty, but in her case I think I'd make an exception.
Moralising the red tooth and claw
Intellectually fortified by an excellent STANDPOINT team dinner, which included a sustained clash between Lord Lawson and Sir Tom Stoppard about global warming, I've decided to rise above Russian pagans and recipes for thrush stew this morning:
My friend Simon Heffer has a marvellous piece in today's Telegraph about Cameron's speech at Davos. As Simon says there's something depressing about trying to board the fashionable anti-capitalist bandwagon. We've seen the major alternatives and they don't work.
Of course we've been here before. My book Earthly Powers has a long chapter on attempts by Christian industrialists in the nineteenth century to knock the very sharp edges off the industrial revolution in the form of highly localised Owenite experiments, albeit devoid of the totalitarian featues of New Lanark. Many, though not all, were Social Catholics, inspired by the teachings of Leo XIII. I'm not sure how any of that could be adapted to a globalised economy involving a host of political philosophies and creeds (or none) but re-visiting it might be worthwhile.
Only in Australia
Historical Baggage
Autarchy
"Mississippi Will", a name redolent of roadkill, but in reality a man of great refinement, has provided a most helpful link for any Brits starving as a light snowfall (its hardly 1962) appears to have paralysed the country. For the second day the post has not arrived. Suddenly the depredations of our cats seem useful- providing as they do ingredients for the Roman receipe for stuffed doormice. I was going to comment on Wen Jibao's visit - the FT had an insightful interview with him yesterday - but I've got to figure out German-Japanese relations in 1941 instead.
Work and Snow
By some happy coincidence the heavy snowfall coincides with a long chapter I am writing on the Eastern Front in WW2. Gingerly marching to buy the FT this morning I narrowly avoided falling over because of iced footprints......its not cold outside, unlike December 1941 in Russia when it fell to -40. The diaries and letters of General Heinrici frequently allude to his breath freezing or the fact that it was painful to breath at all.
Of course, too much is made of the impact of General Winter in 1941-45. After all, the Soviets were just as badly affected by it as the Germans and their allies, as one can see from their rather indifferent counter-offensives between January-June 1942. The Germans made no provision for winter kit because they imagined they would have pulled out most of their troops by October, leaving 60 divisions stationed in Russia along with air fleets to pummel Russian industry in the Urals. By the time they realised how bad things would get, they couldn't spare 255 trains to move warmer clothing, although they found space to deport German Jews. Still, Hitler intervened and told the troops to take the fur hats, scarves and felt boots from Russian POWs, three million of whom then froze to death.
Difficult to decide about the crimes of the Wehrmacht. Some 18 million men served in the armed forces in the Nazi era. Estimates of criminal activity range from 5% to 60-80%, a disparity that is impossible to bridge with some judicious compromise. Also, in the East, the vast majority of troops (say 3 million) were at the front from which civilians were expelled, with only 100,000 men policing rear areas roughly the size of India. Anyway. There are icicles on the window and a crow is sitting on a branch with the turrets of Surrey Cricket Ground in the background, which I will have to imagine are the domes of the Kremlin.
A Source of Sense
My fellow Standpoint advisory board member Frank Field has a characteristically clear-eyed piece in today's Mail on Sunday. What he says about the composition of the workforce at the 2012 Olympics is particularly troubling.
Meanwhile, amidst all the junk circulars for builders, minicabs, pizzas and takeaways, something useful has at last arrived. A Professor Elhadj Bafode is offering us OCCULT SCIENCES AND THE MOST POWERFUL SPELL. Luckily, I'm not doing exams, and don't face any court cases, except possibly a bit of libel trouble, or have problems with immigration. However, further down the list of problems he can solve, Professor Bafode says 'I will protect you from all Jealous ENEMIES, WITCHCRAFT (Black Magic) and an BAD OBSTACLES that are blocking your success'. There are some people who should be very afraid. YOU KNOW WHO YOU ARE. The Professor's style is catching......reminiscent as it is of African dictators like Daniel Arap Moi.
Lincolnshire Raging
A brilliant piece in today's Times
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/columnists/janice_turner/article5622048.ece
on the demonstrations against Total's strange resort to Italian and Portuguese workers in Lincolnshire when there are self-evidently lots of skilled engineers available in a county where unemployment has risen 47% in a year.
Predictably, last night's Channel 4 News insinuated that the BNP were involved, whereas what they filmed was a van decorated with BNP slogans (ie the one used by our prime minister) opportunitically roving around the general vicinity of the demostrations. If British workers demonstrate, they must be fascists, seemed to be the juvenile reasoning.
The Left clearly intends to run with this one. Last night I heard David Blunkett on Any Questions burbling on about Germany in the 1930s in answer to a question about this country's extreme economic plight. Voters will have a choice, he claimed, between moderate Social Democrats and Nazis at the next election, at which point the excellent Simon Heffer pointed out that they might also vote for moderate Conservatives. The Left has always had a cynical interest in ramping up the threat of 'Fascism' and we are seeing it happen now.
Spooky
This item in today's Telegraph
caught my eye, especially the bit about passing through the walls of the morgue. Brrrrr. Spooky. How do they know it is the ghost of a Roman soldier rather than an 18th century highwayman?
France and Britain
Went to a brilliant talk at PolicyExchange at lunchtime by Gilles Kepel, the SciencePo Franco-Czech expert on the Jihadis. Take my word for it; his books are amazingly good. He argued that the British are now beginning to see the light, ie abandoning multi-culti and becoming more like the French, who since 1996 have suffered no major terrorist incident. He delicately hinted that imperial Britain as historians "Collydine and Co" have reinvented it has systemic identity problems that do not exist in France 'une et indivisible', notwithstanding the Corsicans and Basques about who he made some droll remarks that might get him killed.
Among the striking observations he made were that the Deobandists we have here imported an inherited besieged mentality from having lived in majority Hindu India before partition which they have transposed on to us; that no Arab woman in France wants to marry another Arab, whereas in Britain the Pakistanis go home to find their brides; and among French Muslims there is no equivalent to the 400,000 Anglo-Pakistanis who go 'home' each year. Who in their right mind would go home to Algeria? An Algerian friend of mine who does immediately arms himself when he visits his family, some of whom have been killed by either the jihadis or the police in the ongoing dirty war. Kepel also dismissed the idea that mini caliphates are being formed in the troubled Banlieus- its all about needing 'respect' and jobs to replace those in the car plants. He ended by urging greater Anglo-French cooperation in dealing with this problem; let's hope the Home and Foreign Office people he's seeing today and tomorrow are listening.
Russia's Pagan Terrorists
In addition to criminal gangs, Islamists and seperatists, Russia's security services face a new challenge: pagan terrorists.
Several people have been charged with the murder of ten foreigners and multiple bomb attacks on both Metro stations and MacDonalds. The culprits are called Rodnoverie, that is devotees of pre-Orthodox Slavic religions. They are too young to remember Communism, or its suppression of the Russian Orthodox Church, which they regard as the historic oppressor of the country's true ancient religion.
They have a heavy metal band, called "Arkona", what else, and sacred texts, The Book of Veles, although the original- written on wooden planks -allegedly disappeared in the Second World War. I've heard that Elberry actually has them propped up between those ancient Egyptian figures in his garden.
Now as it happens, in 1979 I went to Kap Arkona, on the island of Ruegen off what was then the DDR. After a false start, which involved inadvertently boarding a 5am troop train returning to Mother Russia, which certainly perplexed the policemen who checked my passport, I finally reached my destination, although a hyper-nervous taxi driver dropped me off some miles from the cliffs. Perhaps he thought I was going to jump off?
My mission was to see the remains of the temple of Svantovit, a major Slavic deity, for I was doing a PhD in medieval Prussian history at the time. I tried to explain that to a couple of bemused Volksarmee soldiers happily jamming the TV reception from Denmark. Anyway, not much to see at Kap Arkona and I contrived to spend the night in a bus shelter waiting for the first bus back. Incidentally. according to the chronicles I read at the time, the priests who tended Svantovit's temple had to hold their breath as they swept it out. That's all I can remember after a thirty years interval. Good luck to the FSB with this one.
The BBC has pangs of self-doubt
Yesterday I caught a couple of the items that dealt with the crisis at the BBC. On Panorama, the comedian Frank Skinner skilfully narrowed the debate to one about how much swearing there should be on publicly funded TV. Attempts by Charles Moore to broaden the debate to the connection between the coarsening of TV and the 'broken society' were not pursued.
Later, Janet Daley and Greg Dyke joined Paxman to discuss the BBC again. The discussion followed a slot where creepy Michael Crick did a relatively straight report on allegations of sleeze in the Lords- I imagined how he would have treated four Tories had they been in the same position as the Labour peers. Again the discussion revolved around Ross, rather than the liberal-left bias throughout much of the Corporation's output. That, rather than the infantilism of Ross, is why - to Paxman's evident perplexity - 'many people don't like the BBC'. Or rather, its why many of us object to paying for it through a poll-tax.
From the horse's mouth
I've never liked the series 24, and not only because I find the improvised plots pretty tedious. I'm glad the series not so implicit justification for torturing terrorist suspects on the spurious grounds of "two minutes to midnight" has been criticised by someone who really knows the score:
http://open.salon.com/content.php?cid=89172
The only case I know of where a suspect really did have life threatening information- a German kidnapper- was threatened with torture by a detective, who in the event, hardly laid a finger on him. The man gave up the information; his victim was already dead.
Insanity
Telling it like it is
Today's New York Times http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/22/business/worldbusiness/22pound.html?_r=1&ref=business splashes with the woes of Reykjavic-on-Thames as (Londonistan) is now known. All no doubt true, but there is an obvious upside:
Since the NYT is presumably favourite reading for the new administration, they will keenly appreciate why we can't afford to take Guantanamo Bay terrorists off their hands- as suggested by lawyer Clive Stafford Smith in today's Telegraph- and why we will not be contributing more troops to any forthcoming Afghan surge. Let them turn to the Germans, who apparently manage their economy better than our governing crowd, especially since the Defense Department has been grumbling about the performance of the Brits in Iraq.
The real sadness of Arabia
Today's International Herald Tribune has a number of thoughtful pieces. The Arab summit meeting in Kuwait of 22 member states was to have dealt with the many problems that plague 333 million people in the Arab world: illiteracy, poor schools and universities, backward public transport; problems with water supplies and food shortages. The article was too kind to mention endemic corruption. Instead, they are currently bickering about the Palestinians and Israel while 'the Arab ship is sinking'.
Problems in the region include vast numbers of young 'hittistes', that is youths propping up walls rather than working. The Lebanese PM calculates that they will all need to create 50 million new jobs in the next two decades just to keep unemployment at current levels. Schools are poor and the universities don't even figure in international research tables. Scientific research is virtually moribund, whatever past glories people harp on about. Nothing is coordinated either- energy, customs, transport. The combined manufacturing output is less than that of Nokia in Finland.
For all the talk of sovereign wealth funds, the Arabs have collectively taken a US$2.5 trillion hit so far from the banking crisis. Because of the collapse of the oil price, 60% of development plans have been cancelled, with grave implications for social stability. Crazy alternatives, like the polderised homes for footballers and their wives in Dubai, are proving hard to sell.
All that should have occupied the assembled leaders in Kuwait this week. Instead, they are rowing about their stances towards Hamas and Israel. The real need there- for some sort of Marshall Plan investment plan in Gaza and the West Bank- will also go by the board. And meanwhile, every western government will be turning to alternative energy sources to do with even less of their cheap oil.
Plain Enough?
Last week Foreign Secretary David Miliband belatedly jumped on the bandwagon of deprecating the idea of a global Islamist terrorist insurgency. He claimed that ETa, Sinn-Fein IRA, the Baader-Meinhof and Red Brigades were all distinct, regardless of superficial examples of cooperation (which also included the PFLP/PLO which he forgot to mention). This was supposed to justify talking to terrorist groups with local grievances so as to separate them from the global anti-western jihadists, which means Hamas or Laskar-i-Toiba.
Leaving aside the former's general subscription to Marxist-Leninism, Miliband would appear to have jumped on the wrong bus.
A line that caught my eye in President Obama's speech earlier today was:
'Our nation is at war, against a far-reaching network of violence and hatred'.
What's the betting Miliband gets back on message before Brown and his team have their first encounter with the new president, to whom I wish all the luck he is going to need.
Arms, Banks and Iran
Further to my post about Lloyds Bank being fined a record sum in the US for falsifying payment details originating in Iran, The Weekly Standard has an interesting report about British companies and Iran's illegal arms procurement endeavours http://www.weeklystandard.com/Content/Public/Articles/000/000/016/012wjphk.asp?pg=2
Again this highlights the emptiness of Brown's rhetoric during his time as chancellor to have been effective in dealing with the financing of rogue regimes and terrorists. Since we are party to the same sanctions against Iran, what penalties will Lloyds and others be receiving in this country? Answer: none. And has Sir Victor Blank spoken about this subject yet?
Telling it plain and straight
My favourite business journalist, Jeff Randall, has a very sharp piece on this country's economic woes in today's Telegraph, which is very funny about Yvette Cooper, who was given a hard time by Philip Hammond and Vince Cable on TV last night. Even that Labour robot seemed unsteady on her brief:
Watching Brown and Darling droning on yesterday, as RBS shares plunged to 11p, the most frightening thing was the unfathomable levels of debt these banks have racked up, and the open-endedness of the liabilities of the tax payer to bale them out. Talk of insuring against toxic debt raised the prospect of the problem spreading from the banking to the insurance sector. I suppose its a sign of the times that I tried to phone a friend yesterday to find out what bankruptcy has meant for Iceland and Ireland- and hence for us, surely the next in line, as the pound plunges down.
Some Insights from Gaza
Today's Guardian has this brief piece http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/jan/19/gaza-hamas-ceasefire which suggests that, given the chance to speak freely, many Gazans blame Hamas for the devastation they have experienced.
Yet on last night's ITV news, there was a masked figure, cradling his AK-47, wagging that finger and enjoining the 'cowardly' Israelis to come back and fight mano a mano. He should be careful for what he wishes.
Forked Tongues
The Mail on Sunday has an important story http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1120831/Muslim-civil-servant-suspended-killing-British-troops-justified-blog.html about a civil servant in the Treasury whose personal blog seems to say very different things from the dozens of 'moderate' Muslim bodies he is involved with. Nice work if you can get it. A couple of questions come to mind, apart from the issue of treason which several Mail readers mention in their comments on the piece.
What due diligence is being exercised before someone like this is viewed as an appropriate interlocutor for British government agencies concerned with 'radicalisation'- for surely his views are pretty 'radical' in themselves? And what role did he (or his Islamic Civil Servants Association) play in inclining the Treasury towards licensing the introduction of sharia banking in the UK? Why do we have Islamic Civil Service associations anyway?
There is also a further worrying issue. The government seems to be reverting to the default position of the "covenant of security", under which provided extremists didn't cause trouble here, they were free to agitate against our allies abroad. We know where that led: Londonistan. Now the line seems to be that its perfectly alright to express the most violent attitudes to Israel, provided this doesn't spill over into violence on our streets. Fear of that seems to have spread to the police, with one leading Muslim police officer being allowed by his superiors to take part in demonstrations against Israeli actions in Gaza.
I will be following very closely whether the suspension of this individual results in his being fired, with the removal of all pension rights.
Two good books
An appropriate read for this chilly weather has been Robert Edwards's White Death about the Soviet invasion of Finland in December 1939. The Finns fought them to a draw in a campaign of 105 days, in conditions where it was sometimes -38 degrees, before having to cede vast tracts of territory under the Treaty of Moscow.
I liked the cut of Carl Gustav Mannerheim; a sort of Finnish Ataturk in a white fur hat rather than a fez, who masterminded 200,000 Finns holding back a Red horde of 1.2 million. Elsewhere I noted, in a very compelling book of documents Yale UP has produced on Katyn, that the Soviets may have been so keen to create space for incoming Finnish POWs that they decided to shoot the Poles they already had in similar circumstances. Or Stalin was peeved that General Sikorski had volunteered Poles for an Anglo-French intervention that never came.
Another brilliant book was a biography of the Polish SOE agent Christine Granville who had a distinguished war in Poland, the Balkans and France.
The book gives a great sense of cosmopolitan dislocation: she never owned a house and inhabited cafes rather than cook. Indeed she turned down the legacy of a house in London after the war.
After the war she worked as a stewardess on liners going to South Africa. A semi-schizophrenic fellow steward developed an obsession with her, so much so, that one night he stabbed her to death in a London hotel laundry store. He was hanged.
A warning to two criminals
Every evening when we are about to cook, the murderous duo who enjoy Savoy Hotel conditions in our house drag in a fieldmouse, frog or bird. I have had enough of trying to cook while one of these poor things are chased, tossed and killed for an hour, with Mrs B telling me 'to kill it'. I can't bring myself to polish off a crippled mouse, let alone a finch or similar small bird. Its not as if they are starving- rather just malicious.
Now there is a solution: www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-1114922/Robo-cat-The-purrfect-pet-allergy-prone-owner.html
The duo are now on notice that unless they stop, I'm going to replace them with one of these, which seem to have all the advantages and none of the downsides of the real thing.
A British Banking Story
An Excellent Proposal
Every Picture
Itchy Reading
Imagine
After an angry, inevitably, celebrity-studded rally in Trafalgar Square, groups of Jews descended on Brick Lane to assault anyone visibly identified as a Muslim. Some burst into a curry house and attacked the diners, tugging at their beards while shouting Oi Vey. A rabbi is rumoured to have tried to strangle a waiter with a rolled up prayer shawl. Outside one of the many mosques in the area, the Jews chanted 'Death to the Earabs' (in emulation of the Palestinian supporter's 'Death to the Juices' (sic) placard I saw last week).
Elsewhere, irate Jews rioted outside the Iranian and Syrian embassies, blaming them for the rocket attacks in Gaza, while mysterious Jewish websites published lists of prominent Muslims who they threatened to kill. In Bradford an imam was dragged from his car and beaten up by two men on a day trip from Stamford Hill.
Meanwhile, a group of well-known Jews published a letter in the newspapers warning the British government that if it didn't adjust its pro-Arab foreign policy, there would be a corresponding radicalisation of the British Jewish community who might resume terrorist attacks on public transport.
Faced with such concerted manifestations of hysterical anger, the police decided to arrest any Muslims provocatively sporting a Palestinian keffiyah. Tantalised by Jewish violence, the BBC sent several admiring reporters to tell their story to a wider public, giving a new spin to the saw 'Jews means News'. My God how they must have suffered to be this angry, threatening Muslims with something ominously called a 'Holocaust'. Grovelling interviews were conducted with Israeli spokesmen because of their remote connection with these wild-eyed Anglo-Jews. The IDF became heroes over night.....
All of which is only as incredible as what we are witnessing now here in London.
Rock On
With snow swirling around outside our house, a 'research story' from academia may amuse www.telegraph.co.uk/scienceandtechnology/science/sciencenews/4108867/Stonehenge-was-giant-concert-venue.html.
A prof called Rupert, who does a bit of DJaying on the side, asserts that Stonehenge was a prehistoric rock concert venue. There doesn't seem to be anything other than comparative acoustic evidence for this assertion, but never mind. Try mentally populating Avebury or Stonehenge with Bono, Geldof and Annie Lennox look alikes. What causes would they have espoused? So much 'research' seems like recyclable column inch filler. Do these people get grants?
Speaking of Avebury, we once stayed in a delightful B&B on the Kennet run by a retired Marines officer. At breakfast our fellow guests, a sleek Californian couple who had 'retired' in their forties, announced that they were witches who had come for the Solstice. Try that conversational gambit over a boiled egg and toast.
Our central heating system broke down yesterday. It was so cold that even the fire I lit never seemed to emit enough heat. Since I was reading a rather good biography of General Wavell, I toughed it out in the spirit of those times. After returning from the Ballet, my wife called British Gas with whom we have a HomeServe agreement. Apparently they could only come on Tuesday (tomorrow) because they were inundated with calls from "arthritic octogenarians" and "you don't sound like one". Flatterers. Would it make a difference if I had gout? A cold? Flu? BUT, for an extra £3 a month payment, we could ensure the 'same day' service we thought we were paying for anyway. Welcome to Rip Off Britain 2009.
Two Sorts of News
A quiet and sober New Year
Over the years I've come to really like Jools Holland's New Year bash- last year he had Sea Sick Steve (Bryan Appleyard still has my CDs by the way so I haven't heard him in a while) and this year Martha and the Vandelas, Duffy, and a girl called Tin Tin who were all great. The distant reverberations of the riverside firework display added bass notes. If any one still has any money, you should also head to Ronnie Scott's to see Ray Gelato- a Louis Prima like saxophonist and singer who looks uncannily like Robert De Niro in Casino. That will give you the needed uplift to face 2009: Mister Policeman Don't Touch Da Bananas. And yes I remained sober so this morning I'm full of beans.
My resolution is to do more gardening this year- both in our tiny outside yard, and on the third floor terrace. According to a wonderful book we were given called London's Secret Gardens, tree ferns are good for height and shade.
Anyway, a Happy New Year to all Standpoint readers and subscribers!
Meanwhile....
The eyes of the world are currently focused on Gaza. Although many commentators have linked Israeli military activity to the forthcoming elections, few have remarked that Palestinian elections are also scheduled. The reckless decision of Hamas to call off its ceasefire and continue firing rockets at Israel may be part of an attempt to compensate for its woeful misgovernment in Gaza, conditions which would normally send voters back to Fatah.
Meanwhile, this news from Pakistan http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20081229/ap_on_re_as/as_pakistan_valley_of_fear/ is is equally worrying since the Swat Valley is only 100 miles from Islamabad.
Australia
Much as I love Australia, it does have more things that can kill you than anywhere else. I've never been tempted to swim there for reasons all too apparent in this story from today's Guardian: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2008/dec/28/australia-sharks-attacks although my wife has happily swum at Byron Bay. I liked the sound of Mr Guest- clearly a philosophical sort of chap, until he was eaten that is.
Happy Christmas
Further Opacities
Having recommended Sharia law, and then the views of Karl Marx on the reification of mere things, one might have thought we could get to the end of the year without hearing from the Archbishop of Canterbury. He has grabbed a few headlines, again, through oblique reference (it is ever thus) to a letter which the Swiss Reformed theologian Karl Barth wrote in 1931 to the German Centre Party chancellor Heinrich Bruening. This consisted of the usual thin theological opacities against making a fetish of economic policy- in Bruening's case the stringent measures he took to get Germany through the Depression.
Now Bruening was a complex figure- a former WW1 machinegunner and highly educated economist. Those who apologise for the reckless welfare spending indulged in by earlier Weimar governments tend to call him the 'Hunger Chancellor' who made things so bad that people turned to Hitler. They overlook the role of the period of hyper-inflation in 1923 in impoverishing huge numbers of middle class Germans who then switched their political allegiances in the late 1920s away from the two liberal parties and the conservatives. Others lament the fact that Bruening came a hundred yards from the finish line of his marathon. Still other historians, Henry Ashby Turner in the van, lament that one of his successors General Schleicher did not have the guts to impose a temporary military dictatorship.
I can't see the point of Williams conjuring up poor old Bruening (who died in 1970 after years of UK and US exile) except to get headlines by vaguely intimating the threat of Nazism. That is absurd, for reasons I gave in a piece in the Sunday Telegraph last month. What exactly is the Archbishop saying about the two sets of economic "solutions"- spend our way out and get taxed later or control the Behemoth of public spending Brown has encouraged- being offered by Labour and the Conservatives? He doesn't seem to realise that there are a lot of views about Bruening, or what would have been most likely to avert the January 1933 outcome.
Not content with this nonsense, the Archbishop then complacently floated the idea of dis-Establishing the Church of England, only to row back from the thought in the next sentence. However obsessed nowadays with gays and the like, the CoE is actually one of the few entities that give this country (England) a common cultural identity. Oh and he appears to like his ghastly old Stalinist namesake Raymond Williams too. How cosily Left-wing he always sounds.
As has often been said, Williams is a typical academic. In other words he chucks ideas around in a completely irresponsible fashion, without any regard for their wider political consequences. Some say he has written a marvellous book on Dostoevsky- what a pity he entirely lacks that great writer's capacity to examine the false gods of the age.
British Lawyers, Again
Following on from my post about libel tourism, the Washington Post has an excellent piece http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/12/20/AR2008122002096.html about another unremarked scandal involving British lawyers and judges- namely their obstruction of attempts to extradite terrorist suspects to the US (and France).
The Times Are A' Changing
A good report in today's Guardian Media section on the scandal of libel tourism http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2008/dec/18/mps-demand-reform-of-libel-laws. and how a small group of MPs plan to terminate this. We should all wish them well in this endeavour, although the sheer number of lawyers in our legislature may well become an obstacle.
On a related matter, I was encouraged by the way in which members of the Mumbai Bar are refusing to act on behalf of the sole surviving terrorist; in contrast to the gadarene rush of British lawyers to defend British jihadists and their penumbra of apologists. Apparently the lawyers of India still have moral compasses and responsibility towards the wider public interest.
Fog over Paris
The Doctors Plot
Various commentators have been mystified by the healers (actually one- Bilal Abdullah for his accomplice was an aeronautical engineer) turned killers who tried to murder clubbers in London and passengers at Glasgow airport. There is a very good piece about the plot by Stephen McGinty in today's Scotman newspaper. In fact, many terrorists have been medics- George Habash and Wadid Hadad come to mind- since the days of the Russian populists turned nihilists. It has often been said that frustrated altruism turns to violence and combines with a training that encourages emotional detachment. Others, notably the Oxford sociologist Diego Gambetta, have noted the affinity between certain rules-based applied sciences to religious fundamentalism. And indeed I've met a few engineers and mathematicians who are Evangelical Christians of a dogmatic kind.
What most struck me was that Dr Abdullah claimed he was motivated by the carnage of Iraq. We can discount his claims that he merely wanted to frighten the British with a bit of fire and smoke. Of course there is no meaningful connection between events in Iraq and the murderous desire to kill two lots of people attending a company cocktail party and an 18th birthday party in a West End club. Except of course if some deep cultural hatred and resentment was at work in Abdullah's mind towards a society that had given him (and his colleagues) the only real chances they had in their lives.
Some Good Things to See
We loved Just What Happened- a week in the life of a Hollywood producer juggling two projects and two ex-wives. There are many good movies about the motion picture industry- think The Player- but this was really funny in a low key sort of way. Among the producer protagonist's problems were a louche British director (think Keith Richards with pretension) refusing to cut the end of a film in which a dog is shot after the test audience is horrified, and Bruce Willis refusing to lose weight or shave off a preposterous beard. Terrific.
Earlier in the day we went to the National Gallery's Renaissance Portraits show. There are some splendid major works, like Jan van Eyck's self portrait, two Titian popes, and a Raphael picture of two male friends- but I loved the bust of Niccolo Strozzi by Mino da Fiesole, a Durer drawing of a fat friend, Pontormo's bravura drawing of himself in his underwear, which is a perspectival masterpiece, and the two or three portraits by Lorenzo Lotto who I had not heard of. The exhibition seems incredibly well-planned and visitor-friendly. Easily the best show I've seen all year. And Elberry, have you lost a little dragon by the way, as its chained up next to a fetching lady in one of the pictures.
Brussels
The reports on the fourteen people picked up by Belgian police before the EU summit are sketchy. Some of the men concerned seem to have returned from jihadist training in Afghanistan/Pakistan and one had been 'green lit' for a suicide mission.
One is the second husband of Malika al Aroud, a Belgian citizen of Tunisian extraction. After a youth spent in miniskirts and taking drugs, Aroud became a born-again fundamentalist, nowadays only her brown eyes peep out from under the full black garb.
She met her first husband Abdessater Dahmans who took her to Afghanistan where he joined Al Qaeda. The point about Dahmans is that he was one of the two westernised assassins posing as a TV crew who murdered Northern Alliance leader Ahmed Shah Massoud on 9 September 2001. This was designed to preemptively remove the one ally the US would have used after 9/11. Afterwards, bin Laden sent her US$500 to settle a debt he owed the late Dahman, together with a tape of the latter's last message to a wife who was not let in on the plot. Aroud is a very dangerous individual. Clearly we need to know much more about the jihadis in Belgium- just a short train ride away nowadays. I'll update this one.
Big Moon
Apparently the Moon is going to seem huge tonight due to a perigree- the opposite of apogee I gather. Nice word that perigree. It will be 28,000 kms closer. I once saw a very low lying Moon that was the colour of a blood orange over Blackheath. Perhaps Elberry was up to his old tricks?
Meanwhile, why is cleaning the oven the worst household chore? Polishing brass candlesticks is fun. I hate that feeling of my arms disappearing into the dark dirt. I've just made it worse by snapping off a shelf support- the mere prospect of dealing with the grime having made me get physical. Since I face the wrath of Mrs B, who has yet to notice that I cracked the ceramic tooth brush mug last week, it was up and down six flights of stairs to peer into the grime for the exact model number to give to Neff........grrrrrr. More to the point, I have never found so-called self-cleaning ovens any use. I tried one on a big oven we had in California and the thing looked like a pigeon had exploded after I had finished. Does anyone have a SENSIBLE idea of how to clean an oven other than calling a firm that does nothing else? And while we are dealing with the practical- what about rings from cold glasses on a Cuban mahogany table? I dimly remember a TV programme in which retired butlers knew all this stuff. Help me Jeeves.
A little item in the papers
Syriana
The UN investigation into the assassination of Lebanese PM Rafik Hariri seems to be coming to conclusion and the report is said to be due early next year. The former German lead investigator had to leave Beirut in a hurry after he was notified of two concurrent plots to murder him, and various witnesses seem to have disappeared. But the Canadian in charge now is a steely man.
The report is likely to place the blame on Assad's brothers, Syrian intelligence officers, and a couple of collaborating Lebanese generals. But will justice be done? The US is keen to lure Syria away from Iran, the test being a peace deal with Israel for which the price will be return of the Golan Heights. Syria may be allowed a continuing influence on its neighbour. Israel itself is said to be keener on keeping Assad and the Alawite sectaries in power than in whoever the majority Sunnis might elect to replace them. Odd to be ruled by a sect that is hereditary rather than based on conversion or proselysation. This is why some suspect that a Libyan/Lockerbie compromise may result in which some low level Syrian operatives are handed over and sentenced in Holland, while the chief culprits get off. Anyway, a fascinating clash of justice and realpolitik which will leave a lot of Druze and Christians unhappy.
Watch out Peston
The Latvian security service has discovered a novel way of dissuading those who spread gloomy news about the state of the country's economy. The Sunday Times reports that a 32 year old economist was arrested and questioned for two days after questioning the stability of Latvia's 26 banks. A musician who cracked a joke about the strength of Lats was also arrested. This policy would appeal to my wife who shudders every time Robert 'Crack of Doom' Peston bobs up on screen. With MPs being arrested, I suppose anything is possible.
Meanwhile, I've bought myself a hat. A rather nice brown trilby. Fascinating to see the hatter's shop, and how it was steamed into shape with a half-open electric kettle. I've never worn hats, but reckon that at 53 I can get away with it, provided it is raining/snowing so much that visibility (and self-consciousness) are reduced to zero.
The leader of a middle eastern country much in the news at the moment is better known, to the cognoscenti, for acquiring the world's largest collection of the cards tarts leave in telephone boxes. That he never apparently called any of them- as far as one knows- may or may not be significant.
And yes, since some may have wondered, I've been incredibly busy juggling work on my new book, with updating Blood and Rage to incorporate something on Mumbai.
Other Barbarisms
This story http://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/30/opinion/30kristof.html?_r=1 in the New York Times concerns one of the thousands of women who have had acid thrown in their faces in several South Asian Muslim countries after divorcing (or otherwise offending) their husbands.
International readers please note that British MPs are now being arrested
Nine counter-terrorism police arrived at the Kent home of Tory shadow immigration minister Damian Green and arrested him. This decent and intelligent man was held for nine hours in a London police station, and questioned about leaked Home Office documents connected with such immigration scandals as illegals being employed as 'licensed' security guards.
This is on a day when it is emerging that Anglo-Pakistani Islamists were among those captured by Indian police in Mumbai. I have a piece in the Mail today on the attacks. You'd think the British police had more urgent tasks- regarding the involvement, yet again, of British citizens in terrorism- than poking around in the affairs of an MP whose role is to examine government policy on behalf of the public. Perhaps they could follow up stories in India Express about one of the masterminds of the 2007 Mumbai railway attacks being in Birmingham?
Senior Tories are talking about Stalinism, and comparing the arrest with the practices of Robert Mugabe. They are right. And the public should back them in finding out how high up the order to arrest Green goes. If any Home Office minister was involved- and Ken Clarke and David Davies think it likely- then this is one outrage too far.
Shop Till We Drop
Artists and Occupations
Burn after Reading
India has the right idea
Leaden Silence
George is back home
The Eleventh Hour
Bright winter sunshine on this day of national remembrance. I shall be thinking about three uncles who died in the Great War and who are buried at Tyne Cot and Knightsbridge Cemetery at Mesnil Menart. Harper Collins have just brought out a beautiful book on Lutyens and war memorials by the way. Do I detect a subtle shift away from the 1960s tendency to regard the First World War as pointless as epitomised in 'Oh What a Lovely War'? Imagine a Germany as powerful as it was after Brest Litovsk and how long an armed truce with that vast entity would have lasted. We probably would not have had Hitler's war, but war with the 'restless Reich' there would probably have been. Anyway, you can read my thoughts on the long-term consequences of the war in the last of the pamphlet series the Guardian is running this week. I think it appears on Saturday.
Others are celebrating the 150th anniversary of gin and tonic, favoured drink of many of my American acquaintances. Apparently the Indian tonic did away with the Hogarthian tawdriness of gin (lane), indeed it made it seem medicinal because of the (insignificant) dosage of quinine. While I like Indian tonic water, and sometimes drink it on a hot day, my feeling about gin was influenced by descriptions of it as vaguely oily and unpleasant in Orwell's 1984. Now I know there are many fine London gins, but I've never been able to shake my dislike of it. That probably accounts for my cheery disposition since it is allegedly a mood depressant.
The Bacon Exhibition
Hunger
One Thing Missing from US Election
Thanks to intelligence operations which apparently commenced in September, there was no US election commentary from Osama bin Laden. Websites used by Al Qaeda to broadcast his pronouncements were chased out of a succession of countries.
Meanwhile, the New York Times has an interesting essay on Stuart Levey's War as they call it, a Treasury Department official who like Charlie Wilson has single-handedly brought pressure to bear on banks, insurance and shipping companies trading with Iran. The method involves warning them of a catastrophic 'reputational crisis'. It seems to be working, whether in Dubai (the equivalent for Teheran of Hong Kong to China) or Switzerland. Even the Chinese have quietly stopped financial dealings with Iran. All those glitzy villas on the palm banks will remain unoccupied if the owners are likely to be scrutinised by the US Treasury. Although, predictably, various dubious Iranian banking entities continue to operate in the City of London, as Fran Abrahams reported on an outstanding BBC 'Financial World Tonight' report some months back.
Now if, as seems likely, US military measures against Iran are not under serious consideration, it is incumbent on all those who advocate robust diplomacy (and that means the Europeans) to ensure that sanctions are accelerated, particularly in the fields of oil and gas whose fruits Ahmadinejad has been spending on his electoral clientele as if there is no tomorrow. The 'its good to talk' approach is no solution (the Iranians have run rings round the IAEA and the three EU stooges, and have outfoxed five successive US presidents); there have to be fixed time limits on no-condition talks, followed by stringent sanctions that will deepen Iran's economic crisis. These have to be targetted at the estimated 80% of the economy which is in the hands of the military and Revolutionary Guards. Not only is Ahmadinejad evidently under some physical or mental strain, but one of his key ministerial appointments has been rejected by parliament for claiming an Oxford honorary degree he never had. Apparently the whole government may collapse in the wake of this crisis on the grounds that if a certain number of new ministers is reached it has to be subject to reapproval by the clerics under the peculiar dual-control constitution.
Meanwhile, New Zealand newspapers report postive developments in Indonesia where the men responsible for the two Bali bombings in 2002 and 2005 are about to face firing squads. As I have long advocated, the West needs to broaden its focus on the Muslim world out towards relatively moderate nations with huge populations.
I've loved you so long
Pierre Claudel's Il y a longtemps que je l'aime is built around marvellous performances by Kristin Scott Thomas and Elsa Zylberstein. Its about two sisters, the older a doctor who has completed a fifteen years stretch for killing her incurably ill son, and who returns to a family that has renounced her. The relationship between the sisters, and the two adopted Vietnamese children of the younger one, and how the film depicts middle class life in provincial Nancy, are very well achieved.
Over at New Culture Forum, Peter Whittle has some good suggestions about what a Tory government should do with the BBC. They follow a couple of excellent pieces by Charles Moore and Bruce Anderson in the Telegraph on Saturday and Sunday. Oddly enough, one of the programmes I despise most, Late Review on BB2, came up trumps on Friday night. Four American guests proved more sophisticated than Kirsty Walk could handle, used as she is to the usual third-rate British leftist stagers. Regardless of their nominal political affiliations, the Americans dismissed Matt Frei's warm up package on the 'culture wars' (which Wark absurdly claimed commenced with the election of George Booooosh) as naive and unsophisticated, and then proceeded to balanced discussions of culture and politics. At the end, one of the smartest of the four squeezed in the thought that European audiences might now realise that not all Americans are morons. Brilliant stuff.
Byzantium
Brand and Ross III
Priceless Halloween Story
Ross (and Brand) 2
Amusing to see the non-debate on last night's Newsnight about the Brand/Ross affair. No BBC executives dared show up. There was no room either for any of the BBC's many critics. Instead there were three 'comedians' who all agreed on the BBC's continuing need to dare. I suppose that's the clever line to take if you hope they might commission a new show or a new series of Dead Ringers. Attempts were made by some bland suit on this morning's Today programme to blame everything on The Mail. More amusingly, the BBC is using footage of two different audiences going into radio shows to insinuate that Britain is 'divided' over this 'controversy' along generational lines. It isn't. We know plenty of thirty-somethings who think Brand and Ross are disgusting and disgustingly overpaid too. I can only conclude that the BBC bosses think we are all idiots who do not spot these multiple sleights of hand. Abusive telephone messages (especially to seventy year olds) are, methinks, a criminal offense.
The Greatest Living Stalinist
Russell Brand and Jonathan Ross
Agincourt
I suppose I'd better add to the remarkable publicity a gathering of French medievalists has attracted because of their controversial 'revisions' of the collective (British) memory of Agincourt. One of their claims seems pretty uncontroversial- namely that there were more English (and Welsh) troops than the French, who's numbers were inflated to the absurd figure of 150,000 by English chroniclers. Agincourt was turned into a fine WW2 propaganda film, modelled, I recall on Eisenstein's Alexander Nevsky which was made in the late 1930s. This is not the first time that the British 'few' have faced 'fewer' opponents after historians have gone into the matter. The air war historian Richard Overy has long demonstrated that in the Battle of Britain, the RAF had significantly more fighter pilots than the Luftwaffe, partly because of volunteers from the Dominions, Ireland and USA, but also significant numbers of Czech, Polish and French exiles. There was also no significant difference in the numbers of aircraft on each side, although the British produced more fighters. You can also see how figures for how many of x or y were shot down are flexible, once you've read any first-hand memoir by a WW2 fighter pilot. They are not sure if they hit the enemy or whether it was a comrade, and they don't really know in many cases whether the plane went down or limped home. I hadn't realised that it only took fourteen seconds pressing the button to empty the eight machine guns and/or canon, on a Hurricane or Spitfire. And all at 300mph too.
The other aspect of the medievalists conference -namely of accusing the British of 'war crimes'- is more dubious. This is part of the on-going 'legalisation' of the past, with which comes the compensation culture. Now I am sure, or rather fairly sure, that there were codes of conduct on medieval battlefields, where, if memory serves, the object was to capture high value targets for future exchange by ransom. But codes ain't laws, and they were only observed by one class on medieval battlefields. The Prescott's of this world (welshmen in this case) simply slit the knight's throats after they were prone. The fact of the matter is that for thousands of years warfare was a Hobbesian affair, and it serves no purpose to re-impose standards of conduct derived from the Hague Conventions on Land Warfare on societies which had no inkling of such things.
Here Comes the Judge
The crusading investigative magistrate, Judge Baltasar Garzon, is at it again. Readers will recall that he tried to extradite General Pinochet in 1998 and prosecuted the Argentinian navy officer Adolfo Scilingo. He has done sterling work against Eta and al Qaeda too.
A couple of weeks ago, Garzon commenced criminal proceedings in relation to Franco-era executions in Spain itself, and has ordered the exhumation of 19 mass graves, one of which contains the remains of Federico Garcia Lorca. This is part of a wider attempt by the socialist government of Zapatero (who's grandfather was shot too in the Civil War) to 'revise' the policy of tactical amnesia that smoothed the transition to democracy after Franco's death in 1975. That deal worked until now, and was essential in securing army and police agreement to the transition.
Every single Spanish person I discussed this with in Madrid earlier this week thought this was a disastrous course of action. No significant figure responsible for Francoist atrocities is alive- although Garzon is insisting that the Interior Ministry prove that some 35 generals and ministers are actually dead. Lorca's family queered the judge's pitch by saying they would prefer the poet's grave to remain undisturbed.
Although it is not being honestly reported here, Spain is facing massive economic problems, not least after the construction boom turned to bust, and because huge Latin American investments are turning sour. Worse, from Zapatero's point of view, Sarkozy has refused to invite him to major economic summits. These investigations are a cynical and spiteful attempt to distract attention from this looming crisis.
In addition to being a Leftist show pony in the manner of Michael Mansfield QC, Garzon is also blatantly biased. One of the TV interviewers I met on Wednesday was a Basque girl who's great grandfather, the playwright Munoz Seca, was shot by firing squad in 1936. The person who ordered his execution was the then Communist leader, Santiago Carrillo, who (born in 1915) is still alive, having transformed himself from Stalinist to Eurocommunist, and now to Social Democrat. Nuria Ferrer told me that when she was asked to interview him, she refused, saying she 'would have spat in his face'.
These investigations may help Garzon in his quest for the limelight and to resume a political career that broke off when he was a junior minister in a former socialist administration. Many Spanish people of all persuasions wonder whether reviving the fears and hatreds of the Civil War is a price worth paying.
Baader Meinhof
The Vanishing Iranian Sandwich
Apparently the Iranians have just tried to beat the record for the world's largest sandwich by stuffing 2000lbs of turkey into a thing 5,000 feet long. Unfortunately before the Guiness Records people could verify its dimensions, some Tehran citizens scoffed the whole thing. Meanwhile game has made a welcome reappearance. We've already had grouse and some delicious partridges and will be moving on to pheasant next weekend. People say its healthy food- but does that include the bread sauce or breadcrumbs marinated in blood? Yesterday I managed to buy Swiss Chard instead of cavallo nero for a pasta dish that caught my eye in a Rick Stein cookery book. Oh well it won't be my problem....see below:
Next week I'll be in Madrid where I'm promoting Sangre Y Rabia for four days. My Spanish publishers Taurus always cram a lot in to the schedule, but they've left ample time for what I regard as some of the best restaurants in Europe, especially the cellar like place next to the Cortes. Apparently I'm going be on a chat show run by my war correspondent buddy Hermann Tersch, a living legend of a man......will report how it all goes.
British Boosters
Good for Quentin Letts
John Lukacs
Brain Drain
See Naples and Die
Should we stay, should we go?
Ragnar bin Rolf?
In a sinister sign of the times, the FT reports that the 2001 Anti-Terrorism, Crime and Security Act has been used by the Treasury to freeze £4billion of Icelandic assets in this country, so as to exert pressure on Iceland's government to compensate savers in the failed Landsbanki. Are they going to sequester Hamleys and House of Fraser? It is as yet undetermined whether such knowing investors as local government authorities, who are rumoured to have put millions into such accounts, will be compensated too. Why individuals should wish to put money in Icelandic accounts is their affair, but it is unforgiveable for councils, which presumably have advice about the strength of any given economy, should have recklessly done the same with public money. Before we allow the government to venture down the road of legislation anticipating large scale terrorist outrages, we should be looking at how to contain the damage done to our liberties by the legislation already passed, which inlcudes councils using anti-terrorist laws to snoop on welfare fraudsters and people who do not observe recycling laws. Meanwhile, those nice Russians are offering Iceland £3billion to help them out of the mess. Iceland, I recall, was a founder member of NATO.
What's worth reading on the credit crisis?
Because of other pressing concerns I haven't been following every twist of the current economic nightmare. However, today is explained by an excellent piece by the Independent's City and Business Editor, Jeremy Warner: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/comment/jeremy-warner/jeremy-warners-outlook-treasury-fiddles-as-markets-crash-953716.html which also puts the blame squarely on this awful government's past mistakes (1998 Banking Act) and dithering in the present. This view is in no way influenced by JW being my oldest friend- he just writes authoritatively and interestingly about these subjects in a paper that manages great business coverage with paltry resources. Mine's a large one Jeremy.
Elsewhere, on the Daily Beast, Andrew Neil points out that instead of benefiting governments which pretend to be competent, the present mess will result in a tidal-wave sized backlash by voters against every incumbent government, especially if they try the 'global forces' line rather than accepting local responsibility. New Labour can crow about the putsch that is behind them (remember David 'big beast' Miliband anyone?) but most people have already tuned out from the faces they have had enough of. What a pity so many people are going to be ruined by the time the electorate gets a say in the matter.
This England (Part II)
The BBC did its best to put a negative spin on the Conservative Party conference, with 'Newsnight's' Michael Crick reduced to filming dustbins brimming with empty champagne bottles so as to insinuate a Brideshead culture. No cameras were present, of course, at the 3am booze up in Manchester, where Labour pre-empted Ruth Kelly's resignation, and nor did little Crick go sniffing around the bins like some rat in a cheap suit. The programme ended with some end-of-the-pier light entertainment, with a silly competition to rank post-war prime ministers. The trouble is, the light entertainment has become indistinguishable from the programme's reporting and interviewing style- 'oh no he won't, oh yes he will'.....last night we had three Liverpudlians on 'KULTCHUR' including some priceless lines from singer Holly Johnson about why he found Sibelius and Wagner difficult. The level of discussion was what might find in the staff room of a primary school........
The BBC is also celebrating the PM's masterstroke of recalling Mandelson from Brussels. Heaven knows, they'll need him. They couldn't quite find the right form of words to welcome back Margaret Beckett from her sojourn with the Elgin marbles in the BM.....Now she's a real heavyweight. Watching one of the allegedly brighter members of the Brown government discussing future economic strategy, he said: 'When we find one (a policy), it will be proactive'. That may be my candidate for epitaph on Labour's grave.
This England
The estimable Barnabas Fund usually concerns itself with Christians persecuted in non-Christian lands. However, it now draws attention to a disturbing story from the West Drayton Removal Centre (UK). 28 years old Moftah Abdulghani who fled Libya after converting to Christianity, is awaiting the outcome of an appeal after the failure of his application for asylum here. Last weekend he was almost beaten to death by Somali and Yemeni Muslim detainees after they observed him leaving the Centre's makeshift church. He has now been moved to another detention centre where he is being kept in isolation to prevent similar attacks. His attackers should be put on the first planes out of here, assuming they will not face criminal prosecution.
Meanwhile, its farewell to the pc Pc Sir Ian Blair, and hello again to Peter Mandelson. Peregrine Worsthorne once recalled sitting next to Sir Ian at an Oxbridge dinner. It took half an hour to realise he was not some third-rate sociology professor rather than Britain's top policeman. The alacrity with which Livingstone rushed out to defend Sir Ian suggests that Boris Johnson was right to give the top cop the heave-ho, assuming he wasn't about to be suspended anyway in the wake of Sir Ronnie Flanagan's report on his business dealings. The mayor is elected by us Londoners and of course he should have a major say in who is in charge of the Met if he feels that the Commissioner is too distracted by multiple investigations to do his job. As for Home Secretary Jacqui Smith's defence that he has important national responsibilities for counter-terrorism, that job should be hived off and given to someone else with sole responsibility for that problem. Last night Michael Heseltine made mince meat of her on Question Time over this very issue. Mandelson's return is part of Brown's attempt to refocus the cabinet on the economic crisis. Give him a few months to settle in and his main talent, for compulsive plotting, will be darkly in evidence.
Munich
Its the anniversary of the Munich agreements. And I'm reading Louis MacNeice's Autumn Journal written over three months in late 1938:
"But once again
The crisis is put off and things look better
And we feel negotiation is not vain- Save my skin and damn my conscience.
And negotiation wins,
If you can call it winning,
And here we are- just as before- safe in our skins;
Glory to God for Munich.
And stocks go up and wrecks
Are salved and politicians' reputations
Go up like Jack-on-the Beanstalk; only the Czechs
Go down and without fighting".
Meanwhile he listened to the sound of wood being chopped as the trees were cleared on Primrose Hill for anti-aircraft guns and the royal parks chiselled with trenches to use as bomb shelters. The newspapers are so filled with economic disaster (although the Mail has a nice ten ways to cheer yourself up thing this morning) that I have taken refuge in what must have felt like a real crisis....
The Liberal Imagination
Terrific essay http://www.newyorker.com/arts/critics/atlarge/2008/09/29/080929crat_atlarge_menand in the New Yorker about Lionel Trilling, with such lines as 'he resented being understood under the aspect of anything so insufficiently nuanced as a category'. And 'I have one of the great reputations in the academic world; this thought makes me retch'. After a dispute about a dissertation, he unilaterally refused to teach graduate students again. God knows I know how he felt. Why are US magazines able to turn out such good pieces as this essay?
Elsewhere, Nick Cohen has a revealing piece in the Observer about the Nixonian-Stalinists of New Labour, plotting nastinesses over too many drinks. Sounds like the Beavor's Retreat bar at the LSE where sundry malicious drunks used to congregate to plot, many of them happily carried off by cyrrhosis in the interim.
Finally, I hugely admire the Dutch publisher-owner of Gibson Square, whose fine list includes Nick Cohen, Melanie Phillips and George Walden. Incredible then that three Islamists should have tried to burn his house down because he took on a controversial novel, which, DISGRACEFULLY, was rejected by Random House, after an academic in Texas not only queered the author's pitch with a report, BUT ALERTED UNSPECIFIED MUSLIMS about the book's contents- see today's Observer which, to its credit, doesn't irresponsibly print the poor Dutchman's address. As in the Danish cartoons affair, it is the role of such middle managers of global Islamist outrage which is really sinister, but one scarcely imagines them working as profs at the University of Texas. I hope the alumni and donors there take a very, very keen interest in this chain of events, the one means of checking academic license.
Marx and Mammon
Churches in the vicinity of Wall Street are reporting an increase in besuited visitors to lunchtime services. According to the Reverend Mark Bozzuti-Jones of Trinity Church, 'the economic crisis is a reminder that we cannot put our faith in riches, that we cannot put our faith in money'. He is also getting requests for help to pay the rent. 'People are just sitting there, praying or crying and definitely exhausted'. The churches are mounting workshops called 'Coping with stress' or 'Navigating career transitions'. The Wall Street Synagogue is also dealing with former employees of AIG. It was founded in 1929 as it happens. I wonder if the many churches in the City of London are experiencing a similar upturn?
Meanwhile, the archbishop of Canterbury has adopted the Marx was right line. He can always be relied upon to follow the left-liberal herd, and he has. Now leaving aside (!) the fact that Marx was responsible for a political ideology that killed 80 million in the last century, I am not going to be as uncharitable about beardie weirdie as I usually am. All he has drawn attention to is Marx's insight into the reification of things, which he rightly says is synonymous with idolatry. In this case, money becomes real, and the people ghosts. I don't actually object to religious leaders commenting on our moral condition- if they are there to do anything, it is just that. The problem with beardie is that his 'political' interventions are so of a type- unlike the far finer commentaries of Jonathan Sacks, to my mind the most impressive religious figure in contemporary Britain.
Copenhagen
Now we know how bad things are
A National Disgrace
Biscuits anyone?
Menacingly still
You take the high road, and I'll take the low road
I couldn't bring myself to wade through all the stuff about Brown and Labour in the Sunday papers. How long does this nonsense have to go on before we, the voters facing dire economic conditions, get a chance to choose another government? Why is this man still prime minister? The amiable Alan Johnson has long been my choice, but apparently he ruled himself out on Desert Island Discs, on the grounds that the top slot was above his capabilities. He seems relaxed in himself.
Apart from Nick Cohen's column and John Ware's revelations about GCHQ and the Omagh bombing, I was stunned by a brief life style interview with our Chancellor. Apparently he scoots back to his native Edinburgh every weekend, so as to climb hills and listen to Pink Floyd.........nothing wrong with Edinburgh or hills of course, though most of us grew out of Pink Floyd after Dark Side of the Moon. What struck me was the dread and gloom Darling expressed towards having to work in LONDON, a place he obviously does not like. I wonder how pervasive this feeling is in a cabinet packed with Scots. Surely the bonnie banks beckon?
The Saturday Telegraph had a good piece about the creators of The Wire, one of who is a detective turned teacher. When it comes to dishing out honours, I hope the brilliant Hackney born actor who plays Stringer Bell is recognised, rather than the usual crowd of showbiz hasbeens and lovies.
The Way of the World
Brainless in Gaza
The Evening Standard diary had a gem of an item last night about Lauren Booth, Cherie Blair's sister. Ms Booth, who is apparently a little bit famous for having much to say, described Gaza, where she went to protest the Palestinian cause, as like a concentration camp, its population starved like the people in Darfur. The piece is accompanied by a photograph of the ample Ms Booth at the check out desk of a supermarket brimming with food. The location? Gaza City. Ms Booth did not see fit to mention the reign of terror Hamas is responsible for in the strip- that is people beaten up by police for praying outside politicised mosques, or Palestinian journalists attacked for not towing the Hamas line.
Anyway, enough of her, I have a big essay in today's Mail about the hunt for Osama bin Laden. I wouldn't recommended calling the cell phone number.
Undiplomatic language
Tasmanian Devils
The Cairo Dentist
Best thing in the papers today is this Observer interview http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2008/aug/23/fiction9 with Alaa Al Aswany, the dentist who write The Yacoubian Building. Apparently he still ministers to 8,000 workers in a Cairo cement factory, while writing novels of astonishing power, including his forthcoming Chicago. A committed democrat, Al Aswany was banned from the premiere of the film of Yacoubian Building. If you haven't read him then you should. All the big themes of our times are there, but treated in a subtle way, rather than forced down one's throat.
Elsewhere the ever reliable Alastair Palmer has a sound piece on M15's behavioural science unit's report on the backgrounds of terrorists in Britain. Pretty anodyne stuff when I read about it in last week's Guardian. The fact that the Guardian leader found so much to endorse was also an immediate cause for concern.
Birthday Boy Bryan Appleyard has a good piece on time capsules in the Sunday Times. He caught me at a low moment which was why I suggested bottled human tears- of joy and sorrow, some bullets and a piece of barbed wire. If he asked today, it would be even worse.
Spitoons Please
A Touch of Class
Keeping Things Local
What can we learn from Dostoevsky about terrorism?
Michael Baxandall 1933-2008
I was sad to read today of the death of the art historian Michael Baxandall. One of the most memorable courses I took as an undergraduate was the Italian Renaissance at the Warburg Institute, taught, among others, by Sir Ernst Gombrich and Mr Baxandall. A lugubrious man with the manner of a bloodhound, Baxandall wrote such pioneering works as Giotto and the Orators; Painting and Social Experience in 15th century Italy; and The Limewood Sculptors of Renaissance Germany. He has had his imitators (and plagiarists) but they lacked his culture, poise and restraint. The book on Social Experience made the most waves since he revealed the ways in which the skills of craftsmen and merchants leached into those of painters when it came to deciding how much gold or lapis lazulae to use. My own favourite, however is the book about the exquisite limewood sculptors, notably Tilman Riemenschneider and Veit Stoss. Apparently Mr Baxandall had been suffering from Parkinsons Disease for a long time. I will always remember the courtly way in which he and Gombrich and a couple of others gave me an hour long personal tutorial when the rest of the seminar got the date and time wrong and I was the only one to turn up. They could have walked out at the start, but they didn't, and I had a really fascinating afternoon. Gombrich was amused at what the managers of higher education would have thought of the staff:student ratio.
We were in Manchester Square on Sunday just to check out how much Standpoint spends on offices at Nr 11. No seriously, we went to the small Chardin and Boucher exhibition at the Wallace Collection to see Chardin's Man with House of Cards and Lady Drinking Tea. There are bits and pieces too about how tea drinking went from being medicinal (Mrs Chardin looks unwell in that picture) to being social. Well worth a detour if you have the misfortune to walk along Oxford Street.
Holiday Reading?
Flying Scotsman
Edinburgh Book Festival
Own Goal?
Recovering from the sight of Prince Charles's kilt and vivid blue socks on the front of the Telegraph, I turned to the Mail for more serious matters. An extraordinary piece about some LSE academic reporting for Policy Exchange says he recommends the wholesale abandonment of dead or dysfunctional northern cities, whose inhabitants should move to new towns to be built around London, Oxford and Cambridge. Places like Liverpool are beyond repair, and the regeneration money poured into them has been pointless, Dr So-and-So claims.
This rubbish has been swiftly condemned by leading Tories, coinciding as the publication does with David Cameron's forthcoming tour of northern cities. Do we really want the SE to be some super-rich Singapore detached from its English hinterland, with the middle bit suspended somewhere between us and a more dynamic Scotland? I thought the Tories were the party of Union.
The other night I was gripped by a Channel 4 documentary about a couple of women who single-handedly campaigned for a rather beautiful bridge to be built linking Castleford in Yorkshire. This was to be the first step in regenerating an otherwise dying former mining town, whose river was filled with the usual detritus of shopping trolleys. After four years in which the local council, some other residents, and property developers put every obstacle in their way, the bridge was finally built. And what a magnificent thing it was too. A series of S shaped curves on V shaped steel struts with hardwood decking for a surface. People could sit and watch the fast flowing waters of the weir.
A friend suggested another way of reviving some of these places- especially those on the coast. The British Museum and other London galleries have basements heaving with unseen works of art. Why not circulate them to places whose rather modest holdings are pretty uninspiring?
Meanwhile,
The Tories rush to support accelerated Georgian membership of NATO seems to reflect the luxury of non-choice. In the real world, you either have Russian cooperation on Iranian sanctions, or you offend them over Georgia and you don't. The US, apart from Dick Cheney, understands that. Talk of 1938 seems misplaced. Chamberlain's problem was that he was unable to make choices, neither curbing Hitler, nor detaching Mussolini from the Axis, nor rearming at sufficient pace. Merely annoying someone without changing their behaviour is hopeless.
Invisible Man

Since this is an intellectual magazine, although one that doesn't seem to do much science, I've added a permanent link to a lab at Berkeley which specialises in invisible technology. This is for those Standpoint readers who have always harboured the desire to walk into a bank unseen. The reality is not far off if Professor Xiang succeeds in creating reverse refraction materials.
Georgia
An Anniversary we overlooked
Yesterday was the tenth anniversary of the Al Qaeda bombing of US embassies in Nairobi and Dar es Salaam. Over 250 people died in these attacks, with more than 5,000 injured. Of these, three hundred have subsequently died in Kenya.
Four of those who carried out these atrocities were jailed for life in 2001, and two others are reported to be held in Guantanamo Bay. However, the plot's mastermind, a Comorean with Kenyan citizenship called Fazul Abdullah Mohammed, is still on the loose, despite a US$5million reward on his head. These people do not give up. After slipping back into Kenya, in late 2002 Fazul and his teams launched an attack on the Paradise Hotel, which is owned by Israelis and patronised by Israeli tourists, while using two Strela 2 surface to air missiles in a vain attempt to shoot down a passenger flight from Moi International Airport to Tel Aviv. Fifteen people died and eighty were injured in the Paradise Hotel attack. The terrorists slipped away to Somalia, whence many of them had come.
Igal Naor
An item that won't get much coverage
Solzhenitsyn as seen by adults
Today's Daily Mail has this fine appreciation of Solzhenitsyn by Stephen Glover http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1042458/STEPHEN-GLOVER-A-literar...
He was also discussed with informed respect by Simon Sebag Montefiore on last night's News Night. I believe this magazine will be publishing an appreciation by historian Robert Conquest.
Grow up Tracey
Brilliant piece in today's Times by Magnus Linklater on 45 years old Tracey Emin's art of arrested development. See here because the link bit of the blog doesn't work: MANAGEMENT! I can see the Scottish art gang seething at this one:
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/columnists/magnus_linklater/article4466589.ece
She seems symptomatic of a culture in which the inside is being cosntantly turned outwards- literally since so much advertising seems concerned with bodily functions. That is mixed in with a solipsistic victim cult. Apropos which, do you know the one about Hitler? As the Russians blasted their way through central Berlin, he greeted the news that his brother-in-law was a traitor with 'Am I to be spared nothing?' I've met a few Tracey Emins over the years, usually the artist girl friends of a painter I know. Grim I can report. That this individual is lauded and used to represent MODERN BRITAIN is incredible, especially since Brown, G's personal tastes run to Patrick George, two of which also hang on our walls. Nice, green Suffolk landscapes actually since for 60 years he's just painted the area around his house, not his genitalia.
Baader Meinhof


No I haven't established a cell, but I am seeing whether I know how to put images on my blog.
Justice for some
Snoop's Story
Alexander Solzhenitsyn
The Way to Go
The Curious Mind of John McCain
The Future is Spanish?
An interesting report today says that the Spanish socialist government has decreed a number of measures to cope with the mounting cost of having to import 84% of its energy requirements. Motorists will be allowed to do only 50mph on motorways, and 25mph in towns and cities. Millions of bulbs are being removed from street lights, and air conditioning systems are being set at higher temperatures. So Spain is going to be dimmer ouside at night, and warmer inside all manner of public buildings, with people going about sedately in cars feeling like the inside of an oven. Knowing Spain a bit I can't see this taking off, and the public response has already been ridicule. As for here, the huge price hikes announced by energy companies has already had me stockpiling wood and taking vows to keep the central heating off until January. That's because its warm under the roof on the fourth floor of our house- although I may have to don layered winter-sports wear every time I venture down.
Heart Beat Robot Sets Out Stall
Turkey
Turkey sits on a great seismic fault line from the Sea of Marmara to Lake Van. It is also subject to pressures of a man-made kind. It seems likely that the Kurdish PKK was responsible for the double-tap bombings in Istanbul last night which left sixteen dead and over a hundred injured in a populous residential area. Al Qaeda tends to hit western or Jewish targets in Turkey including banks, consulates and synagogues. Meanwhile, Turkey launches cross-border raids into northern Iraq to destroy PKK camps. There was an air strike on Sunday. The government also recently arrested over eighty people who were allegedly plotting a coup. A cache of grenades was found. Secular-minded prosecutors are also challenging the constitutional legality of the Islamic Justice and Development Party in the courts, after a law allowed head scarves to be worn in universities. Although I believe that people should be allowed to wear what they like, having seen the silent pressures exerted in Egypt for women to cover up, I also sympathise with the many women in urban Turkey who don't wish to abandon practices that have existed for eighty years or to submit to an insidious process of public shaming through a disapproving look or glance. So it is in Turkey where you don't have to stray too far inland from the coastal cities to be in a very traditional world, where the men play chequers and the women are bent double under bundles of fire wood. If the courts find against the ruling party- for trying to introduce sharia through the back door- it will entail the bizarre spectacle of a democratically elected government being turfed out for pursuing an unconstitutional agenda apparently involving freedom of choice. What happens in Turkey really matters to us. It has been a staunch member of NATO since the 1950s, and has one of the few armies in the alliance that can really fight wars. It has been a respected ally of the West and Israel, where it is currently brokering peace agreements with Syria. A lot of Kurds and even more Turks live in western Europe.
Sunday
Reputation Mismanagement
Stalin's 'Iron Fist'
The Wire
As a long-time devotee of The Shield my set of The Wire (series 1) has been lying around unopened. Maybe I felt disloyal to Azeveda, Dutch, Vic et al in watching it? We saw the whole thing this week. The acting is incredibly good (particularly the fatter cops and the two older hoods-in-chief) and the story-lines gripping. Nobody's humanity is neglected. I guess the most depressing thing about what it portrays is that crime is just a way of life, although I wondered about all the people in the 'projects' who managed to avoid it unless they get shot for doing their civic duty, and couldn't quite reconcile the enormous sums of money involved with the economists who claimed that most drug dealers live with their mothers.
What it also did, and which nothing made here rivals, is to make television indispensable, in this case to a discussion about crime and its causes. I doubt whether this is purely a matter of smaller resources, although the credits for the series seemed to involve a very large number of people.
A Surprise
Getting up incredibly early this morning I had a chance to take a look at the New Statesman, a weekly I've never really read. There were lots of interesting pieces in it, notably an article by Oliver Letwin that claimed the Conservatives were now the party 'of the poor', although I think he probably meant 'for the poor'. He has some striking statistics: the number of working-age adults living in poverty rose last year by 700,000 and has risen overall since 1997. Pity the voters of Glasgow East won't get the message.
Elsewhere in the magazine there was a piece about falling divorce rates in the US. Although the evidence is only derived from Miami-Dade County in Florida, there has been an 18% fall this year. Apparently in bad times, the costs of divorce force people to stay hitched. You can't really share out the negative equity. By contrast, in Manhattan there are more divorces than ever. One divorce lawyer has seen his case load rise by 20% this year. Why? A trader the author mentions was having to hide the fact that his income had fallen by US$12 million lest his wife have to adjust her spending habits and divorce him. Evidently some are better at disguise than others.
The New Statesman has a dress correspondent. Now that's a good idea. To my horror she doesn't like polo shirts on men, regarding them as a lazy choice of non-dress just above a tee-shirt. Actually whenever I see holiday snaps with me wearing one that is ten years old I don't think they look good either. Can't see what she's got against chinos though. Perhaps Standpoint should hire its own dress correspondent?
Apropos of nothing the arrest in London of the Batman star for ALLEGED assault caught my eye. I bet there were amusing scenes in the custody suite. Name: 'Mr Bat'. Address: 'Gotham City'............ did he send for Cat Woman?
Channel 4's understanding of the word Sorry
The Real Nasty Party
Appeasement
Choppers
Lambeth
Obama's Foreign Policy
So Soho
Arrived at a nice Soho Chinese restaurant last night slightly before 7pm. My wife managed to get lost somewhere around Poland Street (I tried to guide her in by various local landmarks until I realised they were mostly identical lingerie shops and strip clubs) and the Appleyards were fashionably a little late. So I had a quarter of an hour to survey the street scene. Then there was a lot of urgent rushing up and down Berwick Street- where the market stalls had gone and council workers were disinfecting the gutters. Although I've lived in London most of my life, I've never seen a drug transaction done so openly. A young guy in a hood sold something from a small CD type bag to a gaunt couple. Next, a disturbed chap walking about without a shirt lifted a drain cover and rummaged around for cigarette butts. Anyway these vignettes set me up nicely for an excellent meal at Yuatcha where the waitresses look like they've strayed from a 1930s Fu Manchu film and say things like 'Did you enjoy your evening Sir' with an air of polite menace. By 10 when we left Soho was like bedlam with drunks careening around with the velocity of pin balls. The humidity raises the decibel levels since everyone hangs around outside bars and pubs.
And so to another scene of despair- Glasgow East. Bryan Appleyard ventured the thought that Labour might be the cause of the poverty that afflicts its voters. After all they've been in power there since the turn of the century or thereabouts. If they vote Labour they can console themselves with the thought they are REAL, OLD- actually they never get that far- LABOUR GRITTY PEOPLE. Since they are life's risk takers- boozing, smoking, the fried Mars bars- how come they don't vote Tory on the same basis as buying a Lottery ticket? Who knows? The Tories might then have to come up with something to deal with social problems that are a disgrace to this country and to the Party that has done nothing about them.
Any Answers
Envy of the World?
You know someone is worried when they trot out the such and such British institution is 'the envy of the world' line. In today's Telegraph this was the clincher used by BBC Director General Mark Thompson to justify his claim that some people would even welcome the license fee rising to £240 per annum: http//www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/main.jhtml?xml=/opinion/2008/07/12/do1204.xml&posted=true&_requestid=145119
Like most people there are (diminishing) bits and pieces of Radio 3 and 4 that I like although I can no longer find anything worth watching on BBC televison- least of all on the new digital channels that recycle old comedy, food and property porn shows. I am not a great fan of little missie actresses doing their turn in costume dramas- according to Thompson the highlight of the BBC's output. If I watch anything at all it is commercial Channel 5. Thompson claims, melodramatically, that things like the Proms at the Albert Hall would 'go dark' if the BBC didn't cover them. This is like saying that if Sainsbury's vanished we would suddenly be unable to buy fruit and veg.
The problem with the BBC, as many commenters on the Telegraph puff have already noted, is that the BBC reflects such an Independent/Guardian institutional bias- with no countervailing voices at all- that most of us on the centre right are not prepared to subsidise it. If and when there is a conservative government, it should immediately exploit its mandate to redirect a substantial proportion of the license fee to independent providers so as to ensure genuine diversity and representation of the tastes and views of many people in this country. The diminished BBC should also be told that the BBC recruits from too narrow a pool- nice liberal middle class humanities graduates of the Left University- leaving whole swathes of the population (and their views) unrepresented. If that brings no change of institutional culture then the rest of the license fee can go in the next parliament. In recent weeks David Cameron has indicated that he understands that the big issues are mostly cultural- let's hope he understands that the BBC is to his forthcoming administration what the trades unions were to Mrs Thatcher's in the 1980s. While he's at it, his education secretary can take a long cool look at the Left University too. After that, we might even have something to quietly boast about.
7/7
Anyone who needs reminding of the horror of 7/7 could do worse than read Canadian journalist Peter Zimonjic's Into the Darkness. Apart from being a harrowing eye-witness account, it is also remarkable for the way in which the author develops several stories spread over three locations simultaneously.
Meanwhile, over in the parallel moral universe Islamists inhabit, the extended Pakistani family of bomber Shezad Tanweer have invited four hundred people to a village party in Chak 477 to 'celebrate him as a martyr'. One is not surprised that the Pakistani government allows this to happen. But that the event's organiser, a Mr Tahir Pervez- a property developer and the bomber's 42 year old uncle- is allowed to pass back and forth into this country without inhibition is testament to the spinelessness of the British authorities. Rather than simply messing him around for a bit at immigration, the government should issue a 'no-flight' ban before he even attempts to board an aircraft. They don't even need to give a reason since Mr Pervez is outside the clutches of the British human rights lawyers who would undertake a gadarene rush to represent him. Let's see what they do. Or don't we have such provisions in this country?
U Turn
Knives
Home Truths
General the Lord Guthrie has alerted people to the sorry story of how a man only known as Abdul has been treated since he served the British as an interpreter in Iraq. That is very dangerous work: 'They attacked my family, they kidnapped my son and they tortured my wife' Abdul has reported. The family left Iraq with nothing. As part of a £25 million resettlement scheme, Abdul and his family are currently housed in a run-down tower block on a Glasgow estate, surrounded by drunks and drug addicts. Lord Guthrie says 'I am a bit ashamed that a country like ours treats people.....just like this. I think we ought to treat them with respect, to make quite sure they're looked after properly'. That is the military way. This follows on from our grudging treatment of former Gurkhas, to whom we deny the levels of health and pension provision we give to British soldiers.
Meanwhile, Abu Qatada- a dangerous enemy of Western society- and various Algerians known only as 'G' or 'U' to protect their human rights, are being released from maximum security prisons and put up at vast expense in government safe houses. These are not scruffy tower blocks in Glasgow, but suburban detached houses with nice gardens, where the likes of 'G' or 'U' can get a bit of fresh air. Since Qatada comes with a family, tax payers are also presumably disbursing welfare payments at the same rate as Qatada, and his soul mate Abu Hamza, were receiving when they were at liberty to preach subversion.
Rather than addressing himself to how scandals like this have come about, the Lord Chief Justice (and soon to be President of a new Supreme Court) has elected- though he is not "elected" at all- to endorse the outrageous proposal of the Archbishop of Canterbury to allow sharia law to be used in family cases. He made this suggestion in a speech delivered in a mosque.
Any comments?
Anglicans
The problem spreads
Peace at What Price?
The BBC (again)
And so to the Ten O’Clock News. Brown’s anniversary as PM. The polls are lousy, but you would not know it, since flashing up images of Brown and Cameron, the BBC managed to display Brown on 48% and Cameron on 28%- with no apology at any point for this major reversal of the reality (incidentally Cameron is on 46% at present). And so on to a review of what a Tory administration might do. There was not much flesh on the bones in the four reports by BBC luminaries, BUT, each segment contrived to use old fashioned black and white footage to insinuate that the Tories wished to take us back to the 1950s. We had a family fireside scene (circa 1950), whereas in reality the Tories are fully cognisant of changes in human relationships…….and then yuppies with their champagne (circa 1987) were contrasted with dole lines. The BBC’s political editor contrived to speak about ‘the men who may run Britain’ (showing Cameron, Osborne and Hague) as if there are no females in the shadow cabinet. A little later on Question Time, David Dimbleby was not exactly forensic in his questioning of Yvette Cooper, the motormouth Treasury spokesperson, about her and her husband Ed Balls’s curious mortage arrangements. By contrast, Dimbleby had been briefed, by the BBC Newsnight programme going out at that time on BBC2, about further revelations about Tory chairperson Caroline Spelman’s odd remumeration of her nanny, a story being worried to death by little Michael Crick, even though it concerns events ten years ago. A couple of weeks ago my wife sat next to a rare being- a conservative who works for the BBC. She volunteered that after the Nantwich by-election and Boris’s victory in London, the Lefties in the BBC had turned nasty and were really out to get the Tories. Last night’s none too concealed evidence of bias and malice confirmed this.
