You are here:   Anti-Americanism > They Just Don't Get It
 

You can find a similar disinclination to do American homework in film and book criticism. It was telling, for instance, that almost none of the Britons who reviewed Philip Roth's latest book Indignation realised that the "Winesburg College" at which much of the novel's action takes place is a) fictional and b) a deliberate and freighted reference to one of the classics of 20th-century American fiction. Any American literature student with even a basic acquaintance of the US literary canon would have at least heard of Sherwood Anderson's Winesburg, Ohio and probably know that its component stories are peopled by Midwestern grotesques.

This is not to say that Americans don't get British cultural references horribly wrong. Woody Allen's recent films made in London are all but unbearable in their crude and clueless take on English class and English manners. Allen radically overestimates his understanding of English subcultures and overestimates their similarity to those he knows in America (WASPs are not the same as Sloanes, even if they do have much in common). This may indicate a generational shift; earlier generations of American writers and film makers were more likely to "get" things English.

Certainly my own father, the exiled American filmmaker Carl Foreman, had a remarkable understanding of the kind of cultural subtlety that Allen misses. This was at least in part because like so many Americans educated before the Second World War, he was steeped in British literature. If you had read enough Dickens, Hardy, Fielding, Austen, Thackeray, Lawrence and so on, you were much more likely to notice and understand the cultural texture of Britain in the '50s, '60s and '70s. From the day my father stepped off the boat in 1953, he was stunned by the familiarity of places, phrases and social types that he had known only from books, whether he was visiting the East End, a Welsh mining village or the House of Lords. Today, it's hard to imagine a state-educated American whose schooling would have been so extraordinarily anglophile or a course of reading that would enable him immediately to understand a society that has changed so much in such a short time that even the natives are confused by it.

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
Anonymous
January 30th, 2009
8:01 PM
There are a lot of british people who wouldn't be sorry to see the end of the special relationship either.

Lucy
December 20th, 2008
11:12 AM
Although having only visited America 3 times, as a Brit who for 30 years or so worked and lived among Americans in the UAE, Bahrain and Hong Kong, I can be counted among those Britons who love America & Americans. In my experience you're right, Americans are decent, well-mannered, confident without arrogance, and, well, just plain nice! Hospitable, friendly, interested in what's around them - I could go on, but you get my drift.... Having returned to live in the UK I've been bewildered by the strength of some people's anti-American feeling, but you have explained it satisfyingly & articulately - thank you for a fascinating article.

jp.
December 10th, 2008
5:12 PM
Hey we are different places and simplistic stereotype bashing is all too easy. Americans are just too damn over the top (fine in the US but dont get upset about our opinion of it). Your too religeous (the Taliban would run a mile if they realised how quasi religeous you all were). Aint it time you had a top woman if you are so liberal. Blacks have been in the US since the start and are established members of society. Whats all the fuss about electing one a president? They are a new phenomenon in europe and getting themselves established will take time. I would be interested to know how many Americans were in Bangladesh, in my experience they dont get around much. Why does America run the UN? Why are we in the Gulf and not the Congo?

Oakeshott
December 7th, 2008
12:12 PM
Obama has no identifiable ties or affections toward the UK. HIs cabinet is pragmatic, and his policies will reflect this. The "special relationship" between the US and the UK will sound more and more like old imperialistic rhetoric- a relic of the past.

Brianson
December 6th, 2008
12:12 AM
You're right. oddly we sort of consider the Aussies as cool Brits on holiday. Of course NZ and OZ I should have been on my list. Probably a couple of other former colonies too but point made.

Anonymous
December 4th, 2008
4:12 PM
To Brianson: 'There are only two places in the world I would raide my children other than Canada.The UK and the US.' You can add Oz and New Zealand to your list. Two other wonderful countries to live and raise children and in whom you can trust. Enjoy your hockey game.

Brianson
December 4th, 2008
2:12 PM
Canada perspective. There are only two places in the world that I would raise my children other than Canada The UK and the US . So please feel free to trash each other over who is the second and third best places to live in the world.( Canada being no. 1 of course) But this Canuck say's "May God bless and Protect you both" and I'm proud to call you both my friends. Now grab a beer from the fridge and sit down I'm trying to watch the hockey game.

Anonymous
December 4th, 2008
3:12 AM
To Anonymous (posted Dec 3, 1:11pm): You said, "Perhaps the citizens of the USA should look at the reasons we do not trust them. For instance citizens of the UK need visas to visit the USA. there is no requirement the other way around." This is NOT true. Great Britain is one of 34 countries that are part of the Visa Waiver Program. This program has been around for more than 20 years and has been utilized by millions of people, day in and day out. If you consider this one of the reasons you distrust America(ns), then perhaps you need to rethink things a little bit.

Anonymous
December 3rd, 2008
2:12 PM
I think the main problem we have here is the generalisation of both Britain AND America. But I do think it would be fair to say that I don't have a good view of America. The only things I know of America are those from the media, which, catering towards an anti-american Brit is normally negative. It reinforces stereotypes and we 'love to hate' America. I would like to say also that, I have lived in two completely different counties (or states, i suppose) and black people are very sparse (that is America NOT Britain). The make up of these counties (probably a different story in London) has been mostly 'english' followed by recent eastern european and asian populations. Relations between these populations are not strong because they come in huge groups and we do not know how to handle them. The reason they may not become politicians is purely ignorance and fear. We are scared of them, they are scared of us etc. They have the same rights and we are on the road to becoming 'one' community- they will not want to become politicians yet. We cannot compare Britain and America because they are so very different. At the end of the day, why should we care about America when all they care about is THEIR country whilst showing little regard for any other place on earth. They seem to think they rule (or simply ARE) the world. Watch any 'doomsday' film and parts of the 'world' (America) are shown and how each one of them is affected. Finally I'll say that I'll start to 'understand' America/ns when they understand and respect us in return.

Anonymous
December 3rd, 2008
2:12 PM
You tend to use the term anti-American Americans for people that criticize your government or its ideals. By that and only that it is clear you have no idea what America stands for and should be for the world, even though you claim to be one. Your idea of patriotism is a frightening one and will continue to spook us Europeans.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.