You are here:   Anti-Semitism > Labour's Antisemitism Problem
 
Ken Livingstone: The former Mayor of London has claimed that Hitler was a Zionist (photo: World Economic Forum)


“So what do you think?” people keep asking me. Would I come on the  Today programme, Newsnight, breakfast television for heaven’s sake, and talk about it. “It” was not the opening of a new play, the surprisingly good reviews, or the fact that one of the four actresses had to leave the show permanently after the first night due to family illness. Nor the broken limbs of two audience members who tumbled down the theatre steps, on two different nights (making the term “break a leg” a no-go area for ever more), stopping the show while paramedics were called.

Nor was it for my thoughts on Barack Obama’s gig as a stand-up comedian — good — or his lecturing us on the consequences of a Brexit — bad — or even the terrible shock of losing the bright and beautiful Victoria Wood, whom I had not even known was ill.

What they sought was my response to Ken Livingstone’s response to Naz Shah’s delicate 2014 tweet on the Jewish question. I turned them all down. I was — am — too tired.

I read and listened and watched, though, and came to a cynical conclusion. For the Jews in the diaspora, as for the state of Israel, one thing is for sure: we’re damned if we respond and damned if we don’t.

Out of the blue, the papers and the airways are filled with the word “anti-Semitism”. It is all about us. Again. Why? Have I missed something? Did Israel attack a neighbour in response to rocket fire? No. Have Jews attacked, surrounded, blown up, beheaded, caged, destroyed, proselytised, rounded up, raped or hijacked anybody? No. Have any recent terrorist attacks been perpetrated by Jewish groups? No. Have we vowed in our constitutions, on our websites and on social media to destroy any one of the Muslim states or Catholic or Christian countries of the world, or urged young Jews to stab members of other faiths? Have we flown planes into tower blocks or trained suicide bombers to blow themselves up in marketplaces, on buses, and in hospitals? No.

Yet we are back on the front pages and the rumblings can be heard — “Oh, it’s the bloody Jews again. It’s always about them.” Too bloody true it is. Why?

I don’t know why. I am far too busy running the world’s finances and plotting domination. It’s all I can do to get to Waitrose.

Ken Livingstone may be an egomaniac and a controversy seeker, but he is not a fool. He is, like many on the Left, and most on university campuses and among extremists, completely obsessed with the Palestinian cause — a cause which has been absent from the front pages since IS emerged as the biggest threat the world has seen since Nazi Germany, and since Wahhabis started slaughtering Shias, and Sunnis began supplying arms to Syria.

In one foul sweep and 20 interviews he has put the Palestinian cause right back on the front page and in the zeitgeist. Naz Shah had apologised in the House for her abysmal racism, suggesting that the Jews of Israel should be transported to America — job done. I can’t vouch for her sincerity but she made all the right noises in the right order. The fact that she should never, after such a tweet, have been accepted as a candidate is another subject. Mind you, I see the Labour party’s problem. Whom do you select to replace George Galloway when Genghis Khan is already dead?

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
Rupert deBare
May 30th, 2016
11:05 AM
I'm not for or anti Livingston, but after the Nazis came to power, they were so keen to get German Jews to Palestine that they were forging Palestine permits to get them into the country.

Michael Brown
May 30th, 2016
8:05 AM
Maureen states that "as Jews in the diasporas, we are damned if we do respond and damned if we don't " This fine response in my opinion, deserves to be shared with the wider audience that Today, Newsnight and breakfast television would have afforded. It seems a pity to restrict this thought provoking opinion.

Anonymous
May 29th, 2016
10:05 PM
Has it occurred to Maureen that perhaps the reason the newspapers are suddenly full of accusations of "anti-semitism" is that certain groups have decided that now is the time to exploit certain individuals remarks as a potent tool to use against Corbyn & a radical politics that threatens the cosy pro-Israelil political status quo that has existed for decades in this country?

terence patrick hewett
May 29th, 2016
6:05 PM
Sixteen years ago I did my second science degree at a Russell Group university. One night the university Islamic Society filled the campus with posters of such revolting anti-Semitic content they would have been at home in the Munich of the 1930's and I spent the next morning stripping them off the walls of the campus. The situation is getting progressively worse: we have to stand up and be counted.

Anonymous
May 27th, 2016
11:05 AM
The only thing wrong with this article is that Naz Shah did not tweet it. It was a facebook post where she tagged 88 individuals (numerics for hail o hitler). I also doubt the sincereity of her apology as shes is then seen socialising with her anti semite buddies in Bradford on 19th May.

Mark Simmons
May 26th, 2016
7:05 PM
Agree Eoghan. I wish Maureen was on TV and radio more often, speaking about this subject. Due to cowardice and bias in the mainstream media, strong arguments like this are rarely heard. I must admit, I find anti-semitism baffling as well as disturbing. There is some truly awful stuff on YouTube and social media which defies logic and intelligent analysis. It's as if some pathetic people have a psychological need to display a prejudice and scapegoat certain people because it makes them feel better, and because Jews have been persecuted for centuries, they feel on safe ground. Anti-semites display a profound lack of intelligence and a surfeit of cowardice. They hate Israel because it conflicts with their view of the Jew as universal scapegoat and victim.

Eoghan Harris
May 26th, 2016
2:05 PM
What a powerful polemic. Maureen Lipman piece is easy reading because she's done a lot of hard thinking, about the subject and how to write about it. This is the kind of wise, witty lucid piece one can share with people sitting on the fence, with some hope it will persuade them to get down on the right side.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.