You are here:   Civilisation >  Critique > Sentimental Nihilism And Popular Culture
 
Far more likely to perish, unfortunately, is the “open society”. As the philosopher Leszek Kolakowski wrote: “the extension and consistent application of liberal principles transforms them into their antithesis . . . [A]mong the dangers threatening the pluralist society from within . . . what seems to bode most ill is the weakening of the psychological preparedness to defend it.” Perhaps he had in mind Bertrand Russell’s boast “I would never die for my beliefs because I might be wrong”, which is today echoed by Ricky Gervais: “We have nothing to die for. We have everything to live for.” Will history be kind enough to let us get by on that alone?

If we are to equip ourselves for the challenges ahead, we urgently need to tackle this nihilism. For as long as we see ourselves as the spiritless inhabitants of a meaningless world, we will teeter precariously above a precipice of our own making.

We must also reverse our deep-set suspicion of history. Our universities have, for some time now, been expunging reams of “dead white males” from their reading lists. To a generation with fingers in their ears, such thinkers have nothing to say. Unable to sense the subtle threads that bind us all to a shared past, we latch on instead to whichever tags are dangled in front of us — feminism, transgenderism, post-colonialism. These labels are much easier to grasp, for they require no real knowledge of the past, only of present suffering.

We need some way to engage with each other as members of a common group once again. And though so much of our culture splintered over the last century, there is one strand that might provide us with a starting point: popular culture.

Anchored by the conservatism of public taste, most popular forms — film and music in particular — stayed the course of the 20th century much more successfully than their “higher” cousins. Many can trace an unbroken line back to the very traditions the modernists tried to sever us from. If a contemporary classical composer writes in a tonal style, it sounds peculiar to us: too self-conscious, too kitsch. But in popular music, the continued use of a harmonic system developed centuries ago sounds perfectly natural — precisely because it never tried fully to break away.

Indeed, far more of the West’s teleological code might have been smuggled in popular forms than their highbrow critics ever realised. Just as the eye seems to appear on whichever evolutionary branch one looks at, so the same trends that preoccupied Western musicians a hundred years ago are unfurling in pop music today. Melody strains against its rhythmic and harmonic leashes once again, threatening to snap free altogether. But while Schoenberg — motivated by political ideology — thrust this melodic “autonomy” onto his works, today it grows out of humanity’s simple desire to explore. The prognosis for today’s music is therefore, I believe, much better.

Popular culture crystallised archetypically Western tropes that, if nurtured, may still blossom again. It is probably the closest thing we have today to a myth about ourselves — we do not question, perhaps cannot question, the pre-rational sway it has over us. So ingrained in the public’s mind are the perfect cadence and the love story that not even the Enlightenment’s cynical ticks can burrow deep enough to suck them out. Today, like the lounge suit, their ubiquity conceals a quintessentially Western inheritance.

Which suggests that capitalism — for all Adorno and Horkheimer’s misgivings — might protect, rather than corrupt, culture. Kolakowski notes how totalitarian regimes reach a point of economic stagnation and collapse, taking their culture with them. Capitalism, by reflecting more accurately the intricate web of human relations, does a better — though not, of course, perfect — job of preserving our tastes and traditions.

But it cannot look after us alone. It is but one part of an urgently needed review of who we are and where we’re going. And to face the future with any confidence, we must begin with the memory of where we once came from.

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
amcdonald
October 12th, 2015
1:10 PM
The very height of civilisation,surpassing even New Order, is Sia`s `Chandelier`. The triumph of pagan modernism in culture . I bought it an hour ago.

amcdonald
October 8th, 2015
3:10 PM
The new Bond film song `The Writing`s on The Wall` is the worst song in the entire history of world music. It sounds like Mick Hucknall being put through a mincer. Have Tory Party voters made it Number One In The Charts? The imitation of an imitation has reached it`s nadir. However the new New Order album (free on Youtube) is the genius and joy (division) of British/Mancunian Enlightenment Values in music. Or simply universal excellence.

amcdonald
September 26th, 2015
2:09 PM
The police/London Mall Gallery censorship of Mimsy`s artwork criticizing Islamic State is cowardly and sinister (as the Guardian 26 september reports.) Pussy Riot popping up in a metal cage at Banksy`s `Dismaland` is also brave and witty. For free mp3 music/artists solidarity emailed to you send your request to XFACTORY RECORDS at [email protected] Once upon a time in the olden days when people lived in the past.........it`s a new genre.

amcdonald
July 4th, 2015
3:07 PM
The review in the Art Newspaper online by Matthew Collings of the Royal Academy Summer Exhibition actually proves my proposition true. As does Glastonbury in a much livelier way. Melody lovers shouldn't miss Future Islands - their set is still available on the BBC Glastonbury site.

Joel*
July 2nd, 2015
7:07 PM
The writer asks a serious, deep question and unfortunately researches it on the surface only (google as a nonsense baby word) and then, as an answer, falls back on the usual binary paths of modernism versus an imaginary golden past.

amcdonald
July 2nd, 2015
3:07 PM
The Bank of England wants nominations for a dead artist to feature on the new £20 note (see its website). Oscar Wilde. Zizek is alive and is todays Ken `Civilisation` Clark. The public is being a total failure about all this. All our political,religious and cultural `leaders` included. Soft on Islam- Soft on its Causes Cameron etc want the BBC to start calling `Islamic State` the `Daesh`. Why not `sadistic gobshite scum of the earth`? The English language not good enough for the Tories anymore ? The Tories are weak`Neville Chamberlains` not `Winston Churchills`. Same problem on the Left. Kit Wilson starts off barbarously flippant. Zizek advocates creating our own higher leading culture that regulates the interactions between the subcultures. If art is the star commodity that helps sell all the others how perfect for capitalism that Damien Hirst (the Chris Evans of postmodern uk)exists. The Royal Academy being it`s Top Gear. It`s glitzy passive nihilism. Not a Zizek of an idea between them.

The Sanity Inspector
July 1st, 2015
4:07 PM
As for art, the pants-droppers who call themselves artists nowadays ought to watch Kenneth Clark's "Civilisation", and then enlist in the military. If they want to shock me, that would do it.

Toryhere
July 1st, 2015
6:07 AM
But moderan art is capitalism writ large. After all, we see meaningless daubs and lumps of indefinable shape sold everyday for millions of dollars, all on the say so of the art establishment which has somehow convinced that these things have intrinsic value. Isn't that what capitalism has done for so many goods and services throughout history. I do not say this as an attack on capitalism, but as a encomium. Capitalism allows man to soar free and ascribe value to anything. it does not of itself cause us the veer away from high culture. That is usually something that has been encouraged by those who loathe capitalism.

Susan Rononymous
July 1st, 2015
12:07 AM
A bracing, provocative piece. Sentimental nihilism, yes. Creeping infantilism I call it. American/British pop culture was, not so long ago, egalitarian and joyful-now sarcastic and brain-dead. Not sure how capitalism is a positive here--wealth inequality is edging towards a new feudalism.

EVM
June 30th, 2015
4:06 PM
What a pessimistic, ill-thought out article. As one of the 20-somethings that Wilson chooses to vilify with tired blanket insults, I can attest to the fact that this rubbish lacks veracity (I know plenty of young people who spend no time on social media, preferring to work, volunteer and travel). Moreover, this piece lacks historical perspective. Like so many recent articles, this one willfully chooses to ignore that commentators have always viewed their reality as the time when all society crumbles away and culture dissolves. The cultural apocalypse has been coming, it seems, since the very beginning of culture, and we have yet to see anything to prove articles like this right. After every major conflict, art has emerged triumphantly, fortified by adversity. Modernism came from WWI, when Western culture was completely shattered. It was rescued by the likes of Eliot, who writes, "these fragments I have shored against my ruins," as he collects the detritus left by the war. WWII brought us post-modernism and a literature influenced by quantum physics. My point is this: maybe we should all spend less time writing articles that bemoan the decimation of culture and instead focus on constructing cultural bulwarks against the disaster.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.