You are here:   Civilisation >  Critique > Sentimental Nihilism And Popular Culture
 
Far more likely to perish, unfortunately, is the “open society”. As the philosopher Leszek Kolakowski wrote: “the extension and consistent application of liberal principles transforms them into their antithesis . . . [A]mong the dangers threatening the pluralist society from within . . . what seems to bode most ill is the weakening of the psychological preparedness to defend it.” Perhaps he had in mind Bertrand Russell’s boast “I would never die for my beliefs because I might be wrong”, which is today echoed by Ricky Gervais: “We have nothing to die for. We have everything to live for.” Will history be kind enough to let us get by on that alone?

If we are to equip ourselves for the challenges ahead, we urgently need to tackle this nihilism. For as long as we see ourselves as the spiritless inhabitants of a meaningless world, we will teeter precariously above a precipice of our own making.

We must also reverse our deep-set suspicion of history. Our universities have, for some time now, been expunging reams of “dead white males” from their reading lists. To a generation with fingers in their ears, such thinkers have nothing to say. Unable to sense the subtle threads that bind us all to a shared past, we latch on instead to whichever tags are dangled in front of us — feminism, transgenderism, post-colonialism. These labels are much easier to grasp, for they require no real knowledge of the past, only of present suffering.

We need some way to engage with each other as members of a common group once again. And though so much of our culture splintered over the last century, there is one strand that might provide us with a starting point: popular culture.

Anchored by the conservatism of public taste, most popular forms — film and music in particular — stayed the course of the 20th century much more successfully than their “higher” cousins. Many can trace an unbroken line back to the very traditions the modernists tried to sever us from. If a contemporary classical composer writes in a tonal style, it sounds peculiar to us: too self-conscious, too kitsch. But in popular music, the continued use of a harmonic system developed centuries ago sounds perfectly natural — precisely because it never tried fully to break away.

Indeed, far more of the West’s teleological code might have been smuggled in popular forms than their highbrow critics ever realised. Just as the eye seems to appear on whichever evolutionary branch one looks at, so the same trends that preoccupied Western musicians a hundred years ago are unfurling in pop music today. Melody strains against its rhythmic and harmonic leashes once again, threatening to snap free altogether. But while Schoenberg — motivated by political ideology — thrust this melodic “autonomy” onto his works, today it grows out of humanity’s simple desire to explore. The prognosis for today’s music is therefore, I believe, much better.

Popular culture crystallised archetypically Western tropes that, if nurtured, may still blossom again. It is probably the closest thing we have today to a myth about ourselves — we do not question, perhaps cannot question, the pre-rational sway it has over us. So ingrained in the public’s mind are the perfect cadence and the love story that not even the Enlightenment’s cynical ticks can burrow deep enough to suck them out. Today, like the lounge suit, their ubiquity conceals a quintessentially Western inheritance.

Which suggests that capitalism — for all Adorno and Horkheimer’s misgivings — might protect, rather than corrupt, culture. Kolakowski notes how totalitarian regimes reach a point of economic stagnation and collapse, taking their culture with them. Capitalism, by reflecting more accurately the intricate web of human relations, does a better — though not, of course, perfect — job of preserving our tastes and traditions.

But it cannot look after us alone. It is but one part of an urgently needed review of who we are and where we’re going. And to face the future with any confidence, we must begin with the memory of where we once came from.

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
Art Mann
June 30th, 2015
1:06 AM
We're stuck until we get unstuck.

JB
June 29th, 2015
10:06 PM
Great stuff. All that's missing is commentary on the rage that the thwarted infant 'adults' in the West express, when a) their whims are not honoured, and worse, b) when their smug, lazy posturing is exposed as worthless. You need only glance at how Israelis are vilified.

John S
June 29th, 2015
6:06 PM
Civilization is toast. Islam advancing from the East, 'eat drink and be merry for tomorrow we die' from the West. A God to kill for from the East. I am the god to live for from the West.

amcdonald
June 29th, 2015
4:06 PM
The Fall live at Glastonbury can still be enjoyed for free at BBC online. At least the BBC got that right. Charlotte Church in conversation with Pussy Riot too. On the Sunni Side of the Street it`s all austerity, rape, crucifixions and mass murder. David Cameron pledges a full-spectrum response at home and abroad. As Douglas Murray points out in the Spectator our political leaders repeating the mantras "it`s got nothing to do with Islam" and "Islam is a religion of peace" is no way forward to a victory over islamist nihilism and irrationalism.

Steve Meikle
June 29th, 2015
9:06 AM
He draws the ruthless conclusions of nihilism but will not go to the root of it. Neither will society at large. So the chicks of this beast will come home to roost and we will pay a dreadful price. Nothing will save us from nihilism if we do not go to the root of it and find a reason to reject it outright. Without this we can review who we are and where we are going endlessly and come to the same desperate conclusions

Bill Gates
June 29th, 2015
3:06 AM
Awesome.

John Borstlap
June 28th, 2015
10:06 PM
In general, the article sums-up the self-destructive nihilism of the West pretty well. But it only describes things happening in public space. There are many people ignoring all this modernist / nihilist stuff, be it philosophical or artistic. Also: in the midst of all this puerile decadence (of which pop music is a part, NOT the solution), there is the world of classical music, which preserves a fascinating repertoire - mostly old, but occasionally spiced with contemporary music (most of it not very interesting but that is not the point). Even if it is often criticized, it still has a big audience and it still provides an island of meaning and value and cultural identity - even reaching deep into China and Japan. Also, in the last century there have been, and still there are today, artists working on the preservation of cultural value and reinterpreting it for today and tomorrow. Most of the time they were and are scorned, kept out of public space, and where possible silenced by the ignorati of the established worlds of 'high culture'. But there are again painters who paint figuratively (Wim Heldens, Henk Helmantel, Odd Nerdrum, Michael Triegel, Kik Zeiler, Mathijs Roeling and many others), and composers who compose tonally again and produce new interpretations of tradition (Nicolas Bacri, Richard Dubugnon, Karol Beffa, David Matthews and many others). In the USA and the UK, there are nowadays brilliant architects who build classically (Quinlan and Francis Terry, Robert Adam, Allan Greenberg, Leon Krier and many others). All of these artists enjoy a veritable success with the general public, tired as most of it is of modernist nonsense, but ignored or scorned by modernist establishments. What does this mean? That the old spirit of the West is still alive, but somewhat in the shadowy catacombes of the world. Now they are slowly coming-out. With low culture this has nothing to do. The 5th century saw a dramatic decline of the western world, overrun by barbarians, and eaten-away from the inside, after some 800 years of civilization. It took some 800 years to recover. Complacency seems today the worst enemy, on top of the Russians, the fugitive problem, the islamic threat and the erosion of the EU. But in the margins there are people who work on a renaissance - let that be a symbol of hope. (For music: see 'The Classical Revolution', Scarecrow Press 2013.)

IA
June 26th, 2015
3:06 PM
I dunno, Kit. Warhol pretty much covered the pop culture gambit years ago and it didn't end well. The "stars", it turns out, are even more confused, lonely, and freaked out than their worshippers. Nice try though.

amcdonald
June 24th, 2015
8:06 PM
Camille Paglia`s `How Capitalism Can Save Art` made similar points years ago. At the Venice Biennale (representing Britain) are Sarah Lucas`s expensive plastercasts of arses and vaginas with real cigarettes sticking out of them. All displayed in rooms painted custard yellow. With a twee Tracey Emin neon inside 10 Downing St (thanks to David Cameron) will the plastercast arses be arriving next ? There`s none at the Royal Academy Summer Exhibition . Or any round at Nick Serota`s or Charles Saumarez Smith`s. Culture and society exist to protect us from Nature`s fascism and nihilism. Paglia`s book `Sexual Personae...` show`s how what is repressed in high culture finds expression in popular culture. And vice-versa. As for `British Values` Mr Gove could pilot a £5 instant divorce for muslim women. No need for an expensive cowboy sharia divorce certificate. Put them out of business at home and abroad.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.