You are here:   Beethoven > Opera is Not Just Our Most Expensive Noise
 
New operas can escape that fate, since the composer is around to prevent it. In Rudland's Pincher Martin music, words, sets, gestures and lighting are integral parts of a unified dramatic conception, and Rudland is determined that the opera should be realised exactly as he conceived it. Without an official subsidy and all the paraphernalia that tends to come with it, a composer can take full control of the performance, and not just of the score. Equally it is when subsidies are not forthcoming that we see how unnecessary they are. Singing automatically places the actors in an imaginary world, and properly crafted melodic lines will shape the passions, the relations and the gestures according to the inner logic of the drama. The attempt to embellish the action with machinery, special effects and arcane symbols is as likely to diminish as to enhance its persuasive power. Hence costumes, make-up, lighting and a few suggestive props may be sufficient to transport the audience into the heart of the drama. The contribution of the producer is then a kind of visual noise, as expensive as the noise that troubled Molière.

Many people have an opera buried within them: so at least I believe. For the inner life is essentially operatic. It sings to itself in many voices, and we strive in our dreams and meditations to bring those voices into line, to turn discord to concord, and conflict to resolution. Precisely because the characters in opera sing their passions, we sense that these passions are really cosmic forces, whose scope is far greater than the mere individuals who represent them. Through opera our inner life is summoned from hidden regions and resolved before us on the stage.

So it was in my own first attempt — a one-act meditation on the familiar theme of power versus love, set in Sixties Britain, and in the mind and memory of a lonely politician, who is The Minister of the opera's title. This story was a projection of the inner life, my own inner life, in which guilt and trauma made their discordant claims on me, and were yet to find the objective form that would resolve them. The inner life can be given objective form by magic, and music — which makes no distinction between the natural and the supernatural — is at home with magic. It passes with ease across the barrier between present and past, the actual and the possible. What might have been is always present in the present tense of music.

Hence we have a long tradition of magic opera — from the god-haunted dramas of Monteverdi, Cavalli and the French court composers, through Semele, The Magic Flute, Der Freischütz, The Flying Dutchman, Parsifal and Die Frau ohne Schatten, down to The Turn of the Screw and Curlew River. In all those works the drama, guided by the music, moves effortlessly between the material and the spiritual worlds, and the audience sees its own inmost feelings released from the darkness and parading on the stage.

I conceived The Minister as a magic opera in this tradition, just as Rudland did in his setting of Oscar Wilde's The Nightingale and the Rose. In a gesture of supreme impertinence, I decided to follow the great and inimitable example set by Britten in Curlew River, and to borrow from the Noh theatre of Japan. The opera was to be a drama with masks, which fall away to reveal moral truth beneath the ruin of social pretence. I devised a few leitmotifs, allotted them to situations, moods and characters, and to my amazement within a few months I had a complete piano score.

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
amcdonald
July 29th, 2014
4:07 PM
cunningfox totally overestimates himself (starting with his name). pedanticbore would be empirically accurate. He`s now stuck with repeating his `totalitarian` statement forever. And he`ll never have a girlfriend.

cunningfox
July 26th, 2014
8:07 AM
The usual bunch of ignorant comments from the tone-deaf. Get some ears, people. The whole history of pop music (or whatever meaningless term you want to give it) has less musical value than a single bar of Beethoven, Mozart, Wagner or Britten. If you had a musical brain in your collective heads, you'd understand that. Oh, sorry - you probably think a bar is a place where you get drink before the pop concert, so that you can cope with the mindless, simplistic nonsense you're going to have to endure for the next several hours, to justify the hundreds of pounds you've shelled out for it, because it's what everyone else does and you don't want to look silly by not doing what everyone else does. My heart bleeds for you.

amcdonald
July 21st, 2014
4:07 PM
Trevor Bailey is deluded. Scuton`s "point" doesn`t "prove" anything at all. The article is an advert for Rudland and the marketing category `opera`. Nothing wrong with that. What Schopenhauer had to say about music is more truthful. My favourite civilised capitalist academic is Camille Paglia.

Trevor Bailey
July 20th, 2014
11:07 PM
Roger Scruton 'understands' opera in the same many do: certain works are transcendent above & beyond the necessary limits of reason. His critics here have made the standard democratic appeal to Other Tastes dressed up in Continental obscurity & faux rationalism. And good luck to them, for it rather proves his point about envy. So each to his own.

rbb
July 20th, 2014
3:07 AM
"Their work might gain only a few performances, before disappearing into the void like Genoveva and Le roi Arthus, like Enescu's Oedipe, Busoni's Doktor Faust and Pfitzner's Palestrina — distinguished operas that are now all but forgotten." What rock is this person living under? In the last ten years, Enescu's 'Oedip' has grown from one recording to three; Palestrina is still performed often in Germany and elsewhere, etc., etc. Rationalizations, evasions, and half-truths. No wonder he doesn't want the responsibility of writing an opera. If he doesn't want to task himself with research on a simple article, he can't and won't handle the workload of an opera. End of story.

hegels advocate
July 18th, 2014
4:07 PM
It`s entirely irrational of Roger Scruton to say opera stands at the apex of our culture. No it doesn`t. From his false proposition all his other irrationals flow. He`s got hold of the wrong end of art`s ding an sich. Adele`s `Set Fire To The Rain` and Lana del Rey`s `Born To Die` and `Dark Paradise` are also philosophically remarkable. `Is That You,Darling?` by Royal Family&the Poor is pretty good too. Sampled vocals from a film femme fatale,Inna from Femen and a russian poet included. Available from Gothic Moon Records website.

Steve Meikle
July 18th, 2014
6:07 AM
Forget opera. A great symphony has all this without the sheer silliness that Doctor Johnson said was opera when he called it an irrational entertainment

Malcolm McLean
July 14th, 2014
9:07 PM
Surely Golding's novel is the high art, the opera a derivative?

hegel`s advocate
July 3rd, 2014
3:07 PM
Scruton can`t blame the Arts Council for its capitalist use of the term `opera` as a marketing category. Scruton is doing the same. That`s bureaucratic capitalism for you. The Youtube trailer is only 20 secs so we`ll have to wait until more is available. What would Scruton/Rudland make of `Clones` and `Are You Evil?` by Evil Blizzard (from Preston,Manchester)? (all on youtube) An entertaining future in music and philosophy? According to Suzanne Moore in the Guardian the Tory Party has no culture. Cameron prefers Cilla Black,Bruce Forsyth and foreign oligarchs round for his fundraising business-dinner meetings. Where is Michael Gove`s GUITARS NOT GUNS/MAKE ART NOT WAR campaign for the madrasas,mosques and schools ? In Islam Boko Haram is mandatory for the Caliphate but Procul Harum (and all western music)is banned. The Caliphate has declared its evil war on western civilisation. Are any tories (or any other politicians) not indifferent to the Tate exhibition `Kenneth Clark: Looking For Civilisation` ?

Anonymous
July 1st, 2014
3:07 PM
In fact, 'Pincher Martin' already is on Youtube (at least in trailer form): http://youtu.be/_mVeFKZ2iYc

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.