You are here:   Arts Funding > A Tale of Concert Halls in Two Cities
 

Inside, rehearsal rooms are flooded with greenery and light. The concert space is surprisingly compact-surely uneconomic, I protested. Not at all, replies M. Hamard. It has 2,400 seats, hundreds more than the Salle Pleyel. The reason it feels small is that Nouvel stipulated a maximum 35-metre distance from top row to stage, an intimacy rare to orchestral concerts. The front rows can be removed to enlarge the stage space for mega-symphonies. The sound design is by Yasuhisa Toyota, the acoustician behind the impeccable sound of Los Angeles's Walt Disney Hall.

The new Philharmonie is a statement hall — a building which shouts from every angle, over and again, that Paris believes in its public and will take risks to please it, as London seldom does. The hall howls out our deficiencies. It is tantamount to the Mayor of London ordering the demolition of Brent Cross shopping mall and replacing it with a temple of music to serve the slumbrous north-west suburbs. Fantasy time.

And the cost? The Philharmonie was budgeted at €200 million — not much more than a South Bank refit — and is running some way over at €387 million. No one blinks an eye at the overrun. Successive presidents and mayors have gone on record to endorse the project with every semblance of faith and enthusiasm.

There you have it. English politicians are afraid and ashamed of providing for the arts — afraid of philistine MPs, media and voters and ashamed of their own ignorance and timidity. The French are proud of their patrimony and willing to invest in a vaguely imagined future. Half-English, half-French, I am torn internally between prudence and vision, always knowing which quality I much prefer. London needs a decent concert hall. Dammit, Boris, why can't we have one like Paris?

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
Ian G. Sadler
July 15th, 2013
1:07 PM
Excellent article. Similar situation in Canada where Quebec supports the arts whereas anglo-Reaganists want to eliminate beauty.

Richard Grossman
July 5th, 2013
11:07 AM
I commend your support of the building of a new concert hall in London but I can hardly see this catching on with Boris at least not with the same enthusiasm with which he’d like to build a new airport. (A Boris concert island in the Thames perhaps?) However I’m slightly taken aback by your apparent surprise at our lack of vision for the arts. We British don’t have the same history of government / monarchical involvement in the arts - or in anything else for that matter - as the French have, we’ve always been far too interested in commerce to bother with culture: ‘a nation of shopkeepers’ as one famous Frenchman said. Not in our DNA. The French on the other hand... Let it not be forgotten that France was the first country to appoint a Minister of Culture. In fact one might argue that Paris is becoming saturated with concert halls, in the past 25 years they’ve built the Opera Bastille, the Cite de la Musique, the renovation of Salle Pleyel and now the Philharmonie! And as far as Tony Blair strumming his guitar goes, surely pop music plays a far greater role in our nation’s makeup than classical music, cue Olympics opening ceremony? As for calling Zaha Hadid ghastly, a bit much, no? It only strengthens the reactionary tone of this article which anyone not a classical music fan must think is just about some old fogey moaning about the predominance of pop music and the state of modern architecture and why, oh why we / he can’t have a new concert hall like they do on the continent! Meanwhile let’s privatise the one we’ve currently got, after advocating state involvement in concert hall building in France?!

Richard Stevens
June 28th, 2013
12:06 PM
Spot on. England is full of unmaintainable, uncomfortable, acoustically poor concert halls and theatres with poor visuals. Exceptions... Cadogan Hall, Cardiff Millenium, Birmingham Symphony Hall, Kings Place Best acoustics anywhere - KKL in Lucerne Worst acoustics - Albert Hall

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.