You are here:   Dialogue > The Terrorist Threat to Business
 

DJ: Can I ask you about a different but related problem, wearing your hat as Channel 4 Chairman. Last year there was a very remarkable Dispatches documentary Undercover Mosque. The worrying thing about that case was partly what they discovered was going on in the mosques, the preaching of extremist views. But even more worrying in some ways was that the police investigated, but instead of attempting to bring prosecutions against some of these extremists, who were quite clearly breaking the law, they decided instead to turn on Channel 4, and condemn them...

LJ: They made a formal complaint to Ofcom, the regulator.

DJ: Exactly; which was ultimately rejected wasn't it?

LJ: Absolutely. We and the production company sued them for libel, and they settled and apologised.

DJ: But are you confident that this was a one-off case where some bad decisions were made - not necessarily at the highest level? They did fight the case all the way through. Are you worried that this implies some elements of the authorities would simply rather not know what might be happening in mosques, and that their instinctive reaction is to shoot the messenger, when all you were doing was an ordinary bit of investigative journalism?

LJ: Well, I think the overall outcome was very satisfactory. West Midlands Police were found to have behaved very badly indeed, and the media covered it extensively, with a great deal of editorial comment saying it is absolutely not the role of the police to attack legitimate reporting of extremists' behaviour. I think they and other government bodies will think very hard indeed about taking a similar tack again.

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
Riaz Ahmad
December 26th, 2008
5:12 PM
Luke Johnson, I agree with you fully, but as usual, the dissection and analysis is always one sided with pre-assumed moral high ground. I agree that the curse of terrorism is a menace; this brutality has got to be stopped by all means necessary. Although I agree with your remarks: 'The challenge is, are you willing to stand up for political and moral principles'. This is the crux of the matter and this is where the west defends free speech only when it is convenient. Freedom of speech is a most valued tenet of western liberalism and I fully believe in it. On the other hand, Prophet and the Quran are likewise to the devout Muslims. If these two central tenets are brought in to collision, we are sowing the seeds of brutal conflict between two different people. Al-Jazeera was bombed and its journalists killed both in Afghanistan and in Iraq for broadcasting unedited raw footage of events. Blair and Bush discussed the bombing of the head office of Al-Jazeera in Doha. While western media embedded it self to broadcast sanitised version of truth, Al-Jazeera was telling the truth. No one in the west defended free speech when Al-Jazeera was subjected to state terror.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.