You are here:   Dispatches > Teaching China's Anglophiles
 

Very few knew anything specific about Christianity, and even fewer had been inside a church; I counted only one Christian out of a class of 35. The Church of England, with the Queen as its Supreme Governor and its bishops in the Lords, thus required much explanation. Indeed, only when you are called upon to justify Britain's unwritten constitution do you realise how bizarre it actually is. I let a video of Richard Dimbleby and the 1953 Coronation ceremony do the job for me. 

In China, morality may be distinct from religion, but as in the West there is a concern about declining traditional values, as demonstrated by rising divorce rates and increasingly liberalised attitudes towards sex. Some aspects of Britain's 1960s sexual revolution they understood (such as the legalisation of homosexuality), but feminism as an ideology or even a cause was lost on them, though they were equally bemused by the bare-breasted models on Page Three of the Sun.

As I described the changing development of the British family in the postwar years, one student inquired why was it that in Britain the state rather than the family was expected to care for the elderly. I'm not sure I gave him a satisfactory answer, yet his question had pointed to contrasting attitudes towards the family and indeed old age. The campus itself was an illustration of this. Of an evening, you were more likely to see children and grandmothers playing badminton than tanked-up students in fancy dress. 

Their knowledge of the British education system seemed to be based entirely on Harry Potter's Hogwarts. I made them take the 11-plus exam, which most found impossible — only four of them gained the necessary 80 per cent to make it to grammar school.

Chinese schools may teach a somewhat sanitised version of the nation's recent past, but memories are long and the oral tradition lives on in China. Mao worship (in Beijing at least) is something only indulged in by Western tourists on the hunt for Communist tat. Chinese national identity is founded on its history as a victim at the hands of successive invaders and its subsequent path towards national unity and prosperity. This is quite different from the British historical consciousness, which is dominated by its economic and imperial decline, only somewhat mitigated by victories in two world wars. I figured the best way to demonstrate this was to get them to sing both national anthems. "God Save the Queen" and the "March of the Volunteers" (of which the first line is "Arise! All those who don't want to be slaves!") could not project more contrasting notions of the relationship between the nation-state and its people.

View Full Article
 
Share/Save
 
 
 
 
sd goh
September 28th, 2013
11:09 AM
Eliza Filby, pardon me for bringing up this point about China being more "a continent than a nation/country." I think it was Bertrand Russell also who mentioned this in his 1922 book 'The Problem of China'. I would like to think that during your time there, albeit a brief one, you most likely would not have encountered this phenomenon which Russell found quite amusing. And that is, at his lectures there, notable Chinese intellectuals would scramble to sit at the back of the hall than in front, to avoid sticking out conspicuously. This low-profile stance could be said to be due to the Taoist teachings in which 'self-effacing' conduct is a marked one .

Ceri Morgan
September 27th, 2013
8:09 AM
Thanks Eliza - this drew a really good picture of the students you taught. I've visited China many times in the last 20 years and have worked for and with Chinese companies, and you'll be pleased to know that the answering of mobiles in meetings is not confined to the young: 40-something business execs do it all the time as well. You quote Martin Jacques, and he is very quotable, but have ever actually learned anything useful from him? His advocacy of China is on the face of it positive, but I do not believe that his big idea, the European Nation State vs. the Chinese Civilisation State, is either accurate or useful, and like badly woven silk it falls to pieces under rigorous examination.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
More Dispatches
Popular Standpoint topics