You are here:   Blogs >Peter Whittle > Displacement activity
Standpoint Blogs
 
 
Peter Whittle
Thursday 16th September 2010
Displacement activity

So it seems that some of the usual suspects among the cultural great and good - Stephen Fry, Terry Pratchett, Philip Pullman - have signed up to a campaign in opposition to the Pope's visit.

I'm not Catholic, not remotely religious at all in fact, but it seems obvious to me that the Catholic church AND the Catholic religion is regularly demonised by our culture (and in our culture) because it is 'of ' us and therefore fair game. To that extent it is an expression of cultural self-loathing.

It's quite impossible to conceive now of a member of the Catholic hierarchy being portrayed in a book, film or other cultural product as anything other than an agent of conspiracy. There is The Da Vinci Code of course; however even in films like The Omen, the Catholic priest is the evil-doer, the one responsible for introducing the anti-christ into the world and then covering it up. Catholicism is portrayed as synonymous with hypocrisy, and hypocrisy is now the number one sin in our society - in fact, it's the only real sin for which one can be punished.

Most importantly, the glee with which some people have fallen on the current woes of the Catholic church, re child molestation, is evidence, I'd suggest, not of some great sense of virtue and morality on their part, but more of a sense of relief: they are too frightened to confront the rise of radical Islam, and so grab at the opportunity to portray Christianity as just as evil, just as corrupting - if not more so - than any other religion. It helps that the Catholic Church is, so to speak, Western.  

Tags:
 
Like this article? Share, save or print using the icons below
Delicious   Digg   StumbleUpon   Propeller   Reddit   Magnoliacom   Newsvine   Furl   Facebook   Google   Yahoo   Technorati   Icerocket   Print   Mail   Twitter   
Share/Save
 
 
 
Anonymous
September 21st, 2010
2:09 PM
Was the Pope demonstrating a lack of vulgarity or venom when he equated secularism with Nazism on his jaunt around Britain, or was he merely displaying the love rooted in Christ's teaching? SAE, can you substantiate your claim that child rape is "pretty rampant everywhere" to the same extent that it has been substantiated within the Catholic Church? Or are you just upset that this alleged cover-up has been much more successful that the Catholic church's coverup? Do tell.

colin wiles
September 18th, 2010
10:09 PM
"Child molestation" eh? That's a bit like describing Hitler as not very keen on Jews. We are talking about child rape by thousands of Catholic priests over decades, leading to broken lives and suicides. And yet still the Catholics will not yield up these people to the police and continue to cover up these crimes. Your comment is facile.

south east anglian
September 17th, 2010
3:09 PM
Good post. And quite unfashionable. I am not sure they are the "great and good" - just people who have somehow become celebrities, like footballers, and who can sound off about anything and the lazy newspapers just report them. The Church's problem is it can't fight back with the same vulgarity and venom, as it is rooted in the teaching of Christ. Fortunately these detractors are only a tiny tiny fraction of the population and have little impact outside the dining rooms of fashionable Hampstead and Highgate dinner parties. Politicians naturally keep well clear of such bigoted sectarianism for obviously reasons. Die Zeit in Germany has written much more thoughtfully than our British press about such matters as Paedophilia within the church (which I suspect is pretty rampant everywhere if one is allowed to look - if there ia a 100 year embargo on the files, be suspicious, prominent public figures are probably involved in something...) Yes, attacking the church prevents people looking elsewhere, at themselves even. Funny too that the strident secular bigots never seem to mention the segregated orthodox Jewish community when they attack church schools (here since the Victorian era, incidentally) and of course Islam is given a wide berth in their hate campaign for obvious reasons. There always has to be a bogey man - the Catholic church was before, just as the Irish, gay people, black people, refugees, etc have been also. When one reads the illiberal anti-religious outpourings of some commentators in the Guardian, I think of some of the BNP literature I have read. Very little of it stands up to scrutiny, the araguments are so silly that one doesn't know where to begin to answer. But they are famous biologists, comedians,and so on, so one has to listen to them !!! It all has a strong whiff of Chinese communism about it, where everyone has to conform to the top officials' view , and it is not terribly liberal. Surprise surprise.

Ramakrishna Vedula
September 16th, 2010
9:09 PM
Attacking the Catholic church is one of the most important qualifications of a leftist intellectual.And the severity of the attack increases with the degree of impotence one experiences in the face of radical Islam.

Post your comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
 
About Peter Whittle

Peter Whittle is director of the New Culture Forum and author of Look at Me: Celebrating the Self in Modern Britain, Private Views: Voices from the Front Line of British Culture, Monarchy Matters and, most recently, Being British: What's Wrong With It? (Biteback).

Recent Blog Posts
Blog List
More Posts
Popular Standpoint topics